Converting any standard rail to a Holey rail

Bohdan

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2014
Messages
1,030
Did a little experiment today to see if it was possible to convert a standard rail to a holey rail and I am pleased to announce that it worked.

The things that you need are the LR32 router plate, a 6mm router cutter and any holey rail, you can then easily convert any length rail to a holey rail. The router cutter that I used was a single flute solid carbide one and it was not designed to drill down into aluminium. It worked but if you can get one that is designed to drill it will be easier.

I didn't take any photos while I was doing it so I will repeat the procedure, photograph it and add the photos later.

This procedure also assumes that the router plate is correctly set up with no excess play or slop and the guide pin is always correctly located in one of the holes. The location of the holes in the lengthwise direction is not critical as all future measurements and settings are from the holes.

You screw the two rails, with their two sacrificial strips towards each other, to a solid flat surface using washers and screws thru the large holes in each end. The holey rail sits over the other and is lifted about 3mm with a thin packing piece to level it (I used a bit of Masonite). Initial positions are fixed by estimating the location of the new holes using the notch in the router plate. Lowering the cutter to touch the rail, while spinning, will leave a shallow circle mark. This mark, if it is slightly off, will be the only way you will be able to tell which is the copy.

Then accurately measure (I used a vernier caliper) the distance from the ridge in the rail to each side of the slot in the holey rail and adjust the rails so that the new hole would land on one end of the required slot. Adjustment is achieved by loosening one of the screws holding the holey rail and gently tapping with a piece of wood, when the dimension is correct, tighten the screw and do the other end.

After repeating the measurements, and if necessary readjusting your settings, you are now ready to drill the holes. I used a spray lube on the cutter after each hole to stop the aluminium sticking and galling on the cutter.

You then move the holey rail 1 mm in whichever direction you need to elongate the holes, drill them again and you have a finished holey rail.

To extend the length of the new rail longer than the original one, move the holey rail along, drop the stationary cutter into one of the new holes, and start the procedure again.

I was actually surprised how quick and easy it was once I had the rails screwed in the right position. I will convert the rest of my rails this time photographing the process and post the pics.

For those of you that don't already have a holey rail a suggest you try to borrow one and produce as many as required.
 
Any issues with getting the LR 32 plate pin to drop into the new holes since the original holes aren't round? They're slightly oval.
 
Yeah, I too was wondering about the holes being oval on the *real* holey rails… The LR32 system depends on that.
 
Bert Vanderveen said:
Yeah, I too was wondering about the holes being oval on the *real* holey rails… The LR32 system depends on that.

He mentioned in his initial post the he moves the router 1 mm to elongate the hole.  I find this interesting, and would really like to see if it is as accurate as a true LR 32 rail.  Hopefully we all get pictures soon!  [thumbs up]
 
Not to detract from the OP's post, interesting that no one has ever posted (to my knowledge) doing such a conversion from a standard to a holey rail with a CNC.  I would think that would be a quite easy task to complete.
 
Did another rail and here are the pictures with some slight changes in the procedure.

[attachthumb=8]
The two rails are mounted to a board with screws and washers.

[attachthumb=2]
They are spaced 206mm ridge to ridge. Ignore the round circle mark as you can see its wrong.

[attachthumb=3]
Touch the rail with the cutter to be able to check that it is in the correct location. (Second mark)

[attachthumb=4]
Drill the first row lubricating the cutter with spray lube.

[attachthumb=5]
Reset the spacing to 205mm to elongate the slots.

[attachthumb=6]
New holey rail is ready  [big grin] [big grin]

[attachthumb=7]
Shows the LR32 pin fit in the slot.
 

Attachments

  • IMAG0041.jpg
    IMAG0041.jpg
    1.3 MB · Views: 1,872
  • IMAG0041.jpg
    IMAG0041.jpg
    1.3 MB · Views: 1,569
  • IMAG0052.jpg
    IMAG0052.jpg
    685.9 KB · Views: 1,146
  • IMAG0049.jpg
    IMAG0049.jpg
    1.3 MB · Views: 1,052
  • IMAG0048.jpg
    IMAG0048.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 3,122
  • IMAG0046.jpg
    IMAG0046.jpg
    1.3 MB · Views: 988
  • IMAG0045.jpg
    IMAG0045.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 971
  • IMAG0044.jpg
    IMAG0044.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 1,295
Awesome work/pictures!  I baby my rails, but this is almost motivating me to cut into them.  [scared]
 
What does the slight elongation of the holes accomplish? I see that the spacing is maintained but how does the elongated hole help with the indexing system.

I'm making a DeWalt holey rail to use with my routers and DeWalt track.

View attachment 1

 

Attachments

  • 20160302_153718 (Small).jpg
    20160302_153718 (Small).jpg
    118 KB · Views: 1,633
  • 20160302_160841 (Small).jpg
    20160302_160841 (Small).jpg
    112.3 KB · Views: 799
Bob D. said:
What does the slight elongation of the holes accomplish? I see that the spacing is maintained but how does the elongated hole help with the indexing system.

I'm making a DeWalt holey rail to use with my routers and DeWalt track.

View attachment 1
To make sure that the pin will drop into the holes

 
Bob D. said:
What does the slight elongation of the holes accomplish? I see that the spacing is maintained but how does the elongated hole help with the indexing system.

I'm making a DeWalt holey rail to use with my routers and DeWalt track.

View attachment 1

Bob D, any additional information that you could share would be greatly appreciated. I have the DeWalt system and router accessories and was thinking about getting a Festool hole rail and adapting.
 
I gotta borrow someones holey rail. 

Thanks for the inforation

Silly question,  why is Festool still making rails without holes? 
 
More accessories = $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!

They're (mostly) offered in different lengths so you need them all!
 
mazmes said:
Bob D. said:
What does the slight elongation of the holes accomplish? I see that the spacing is maintained but how does the elongated hole help with the indexing system.

I'm making a DeWalt holey rail to use with my routers and DeWalt track.

View attachment 1

Bob D, any additional information that you could share would be greatly appreciated. I have the DeWalt system and router accessories and was thinking about getting a Festool hole rail and adapting.

I'm not finished yet but here is what I have done so far.
http://festoolownersgroup.com/festo...-saw-clamp-with-the-mft3/msg446523/#msg446523

I need to make the indexing system that will fit on the router adapter. To tell the truth I don't know if its worth the trouble. I think buying a Festool holey rail and router adapter may be a better choice all around if you have the money. My reason for trying this was to see if I could make something that would work and keep cost down for a jig I will rarely use but is nice to have. Since putting the holes in the rail doesn't affect use with the track saw I figured it was worth a try. Been busy at work the past couple days and may not have time to work on this again for a month or more. But I'm always thinking about how I will proceed and scrounging bits and pieces to make the indexing system with. I think I have most of the raw material I will need. When I get a day in the shop to fiddle with it I will try some ideas and see what will work. I don't want to hijack this thread for my project so if anyone has questions PM me or maybe start a new thread.
 
A monumental effort indeed for what is a kluge of system that in itself is ripe for errors if you don't use it regularly. I jumped ship to Mafell to get away from LR32 and the machinations necessary to use it. The Mafell unit is trivial to setup and use. For those without a Domino, but in need of a joining tool, consider the DD40 which joins and with a spacing template does perfect shelf holes. Mafell is not busy making tons of accessories, multiple tools in the same category, and hawking coolers, green levels and boomboxes, so they can make some innovative tools.
 
The simplest solution would be to have all rails holey rails. It's been suggested many many times before.
 
mastercabman said:
What does the slight elongation of the holes accomplish?

To make sure that the pin will drop into the holes

I own a couple of holey rails but not the complete LR 32 setup and have always wondered what was the purpose of the obround holes. Now I know...

Well if that’s the real answer, then that’s completely whacky...that will only help along one axis. And who’s to say that will always be the axis that you need to encourage engagement on?

Why not just pull the pin and machine a slight taper on the end to encourage engagement around the entire periphery?
 
As you adjust for the slop in the router carriage it moves back and forth in the direction of the slots.  [smile]
 
Bohdan said:
As you adjust for the slop in the router carriage it moves back and forth in the direction of the slots.  [smile]

Gotcha...so it’s the router carriage that dictates the axis of the alignment.
 
Back
Top