I get similar results from Minwax’s Oil Based Poly, but note that I only have used the interior grade version). Exterior versions tend to be more elastic (and therefor a softer finish, more susceptible to scratching).
I usually apply a dewaxed shellac product (Seal Coat) for the first coat, but that is not recommended for exterior applications. I then add three coats of the Oil based Poly. They recommend that you either recoat within 4 hours or lightly sand between coats after 8 hours.
I always wait and sand.
I apply 3 coats for vertical (appearance) surfaces and 4 or more coats for horizontal (wear surfaces). I always use gloss, and then I de-gloss it by applying Butchers wax with 0000 steel wool and significant elbow grease (pressure + repetition). The wax improves the tactile feel and will prevent other items from bonding to the surface if they are put on the surface before complete curing.
I have a heavy gage clear vinyl desk pad that is permanently bonded to the poly because I allowed it to be put in place before the finish was fully cured.
The manufacturer stated that it is cured after 48 hours, but it continues to hardern significantly over the first 7 - 10 days and then continues to hardened over the next few years.
For the last 10 years or so, I have been applying poly as a wipe on finish, with a dilution of 50% poly and 50% mineral spirits. I need about twice as many coats to get the same effect, but there is no brushes to clean, and no drips or runs ever. It always looks like a sprayed on finish.
I would note that you should make a sample to be sure it has the appearance you want, as removing oil based poly that has cured can be a monumental chore.
