I hit the mother load!!! I THINK. Curly maple, birds eye, figured cherry..

ForumMFG

Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
1,004
So today i came across a listing on facebook where a guy was selling a large amount of rough sawn lumber.  He was local so i figured i would go look.  I ended up purchasing (20) boards of 1 1/8” thick x 15” x 10’ curly maple!  I also scored a handful of birds eye maple and figured cherry.  I have a pick up truck with a 6’ long bed and completely filled it up to the top, and then filled up the back seat of my crew cab, just full of great wood.  Get this, all for $250.  I got it so cheap for a few reasons and 1 reason is that it was stored in the attic and about a 1/4 of each board has water damage form a leaking roof.  But the majority of it is clear and in great shape.  I had concerns about buying this wood with the damage and because it was stored in an attic for many many years with all the extreme temp fluctuations.  Being that it was stored in an attic, is there any serious concern that this wood is completely junk?

The story on this material is that a old guy use to make big grandfather clocks, he past away, and some younger gentleman bought the house as an investment and plans to rent it out.  When he bought the house it came with all the contents and there are piles and piles of high grade wood everywhere.  Thousands and thousands of board feet everywhere.  The new owner is not a woodworker but knows enough to know what he has.  He is more interested in getting rid of it so he can start renting the property. I left behind a handful of 4”x4”x8’ curly maple! Those are in perfect shape and i may go back for those.  I didn’t tell my wife i was doing this, when i saw it I couldn’t pass it up but once i told her the story she said go back and get more!  Most of the wood is stored on the first floor of a garage and there are piles of cherry and walnut i want to go through but this garage was not heated.  So i really just want to know if i should be concerned about the temp fluctuations before i spend more money.  Ill post some pics tomorrow after i unload it and while its still daylight, i literally just picked it all up. 

I was into woodworking about 10-15 years ago but life happened, sold everything, but recently got back into it so im still a little new and don’t know as much as some of you veterans and thats why im questioning all of this. 

 
Sounds like a great find! You are probably fine but maybe get yourself a moisture meter (and a jointer and planer). Even the water stained parts may cleanup.

Mike
 
Well [member=6558]ForumMFG[/member], at least you can make up for your 10-15 year break and get back into the swing of making sawdust.

I had a similar experience a few years ago.  I was looking on CL for anyone local with cherry, and an ad popped up for a person who was cleaning out the lower level of his barn that had a bunch of misc wood and was going to have a barn sale the upcoming weekend. I was planning to be on travel, so I responded and asked if I could take a look before the weekend. He indicated that he had no idea what the stuff was, and he had been renting it out to someone who up and left a few years earlier.

So upon my visit, I had to sift through a lot of stacks of various building materials to get through to some of the decent stuff. I told him what the species were (oak, cherry, maple) and their fair market value so that he wouldn't get skunked during his sale. He finally said that he didn't care, and that he just wanted everything in the barn cleaned out. After purchasing a few boards, he said:  "there's more over in the back corner" which wasn't very well lit.  So after removing the various stuff from the top, I ended up getting into some really wide, incredibly heavy, reddish-dark wood. I drug one of them out into the daylight, and knew right away that is was some type of tropical stuff which ended up being identified as bubinga. There were also sheets (1/8" thick) of the stuff in bundles, that in the dark, I thought was veneered plywood. Dragging that outside, it was the same species (bubinga), but not plywood.

I ended up canceling my trip for Saturday, and got there early enough to purchase as much of the bubinga I could find, which took a lot of effort to move piles (this time, I brought a flashlight...). I had no idea what this person renting the barn was doing, until I saw someone walking around with templates for guitar bodies that they were going to buy.  Then I figured out that the 1/8" bubinga must have been tonewood (bookmatched sets), and there were other woods in there that I ended up having someone ID for me later.  I've made a few things along the way with some of the wood, but still have a ways to go before the rest takes a different form.

Similar to your situation, it was a crazy find. Like the saying goes: "Even a blind squirrel finds a nut now and then."

Kudos to you, and now you can ramp back up into woodworking again.
 
If the wood has no rot and it is not visibly warped, twisted, etc. then you are probably fine. Sounds like a terrific find! Enjoy! The biggest potential problem you face is not buying all you can. Then you will do a project and you will find that you need some more wood. The problem will start when you go to a hardwood retailer and see just how much you are going to have to pay for it😊. Like I said enjoy!
 
I really wouldn't be concerned about the temperature fluctuations, wood does what it wants to do.

The bigger issue is if the water/mineral markings are significant enough to impair the overall general looks of the wood.

Sometimes the mineral markings can be a positive addition to the appearance of the material.

My suggestion, if you do pull the pin, purchase at least 20-30% more than you'll need just to make sure because you'll probably never be able to match the wood tonation from outside sources again.
 
This point Cheese is making is VERY important....I ran into this kind of deal with some barn dried walnut, some of the most beautiful purplish I’ve ever seen ( kiln dried kinda evens the color out) and couldn’t buy walnut that matched it...once gone...it’s gone
 
c_dwyer said:
Well [member=6558]ForumMFG[/member], at least you can make up for your 10-15 year break and get back into the swing of making sawdust.

I had a similar experience a few years ago.  I was looking on CL for anyone local with cherry, and an ad popped up for a person who was cleaning out the lower level of his barn that had a bunch of misc wood and was going to have a barn sale the upcoming weekend. I was planning to be on travel, so I responded and asked if I could take a look before the weekend. He indicated that he had no idea what the stuff was, and he had been renting it out to someone who up and left a few years earlier.

So upon my visit, I had to sift through a lot of stacks of various building materials to get through to some of the decent stuff. I told him what the species were (oak, cherry, maple) and their fair market value so that he wouldn't get skunked during his sale. He finally said that he didn't care, and that he just wanted everything in the barn cleaned out. After purchasing a few boards, he said:  "there's more over in the back corner" which wasn't very well lit.  So after removing the various stuff from the top, I ended up getting into some really wide, incredibly heavy, reddish-dark wood. I drug one of them out into the daylight, and knew right away that is was some type of tropical stuff which ended up being identified as bubinga. There were also sheets (1/8" thick) of the stuff in bundles, that in the dark, I thought was veneered plywood. Dragging that outside, it was the same species (bubinga), but not plywood.

I ended up canceling my trip for Saturday, and got there early enough to purchase as much of the bubinga I could find, which took a lot of effort to move piles (this time, I brought a flashlight...). I had no idea what this person renting the barn was doing, until I saw someone walking around with templates for guitar bodies that they were going to buy.  Then I figured out that the 1/8" bubinga must have been tonewood (bookmatched sets), and there were other woods in there that I ended up having someone ID for me later.  I've made a few things along the way with some of the wood, but still have a ways to go before the rest takes a different form.

Similar to your situation, it was a crazy find. Like the saying goes: "Even a blind squirrel finds a nut now and then."

Kudos to you, and now you can ramp back up into woodworking again.

I love hearing stories like this.  Was any of waterfall bubinga? Bubinga in general is my favorite wood but waterfall, man thats on a whole different level.  It’s unfortunate that we can’t get it anymore but i totally understand, we as humans have caused the problem and i hope there are enough trees like that for future generations to enjoy as well.  But people need to do a better job of planting.  If you take one plant one should be the goal but too many people don’t care

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Alanbach said:
If the wood has no rot and it is not visibly warped, twisted, etc. then you are probably fine. Sounds like a terrific find! Enjoy! The biggest potential problem you face is not buying all you can. Then you will do a project and you will find that you need some more wood. The problem will start when you go to a hardwood retailer and see just how much you are going to have to pay for it[emoji4]. Like I said enjoy!

Lol, i am fully aware of what this stuff costs! And i already thought of that.  Most of the boards have a slight twist and some a warp.  But the boards are so thick and wide that after i mill it to the sizes i want i don’t think it will be an issue.  To me its no different than any other rough sawn lumber, am i wrong?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Tough call without seeing it up close and personal. It’s really a judgement call. Modest warp is a lot easier to deal with than twist. Also if you are able to store the wood you buy in a climate controlled environment and get it stabilized before and after you mill it that will certainly help a lot. Sounds like you need to account for an above average quantity of waste but if you have the space and the savings are huge it is probably worth the risk.

BTW, you are not wrong about those issues being common in thick rough cut hardwoods but if you buy it commercially you can pick through it and cherry pick the pieces you want. Probably not as feasible in a case like this.

The good news is that if you buy a lot of this wood it is going to significantly improve your milling skills!
 
So i have never milled wood figured like this, how hard is this material on jointer and planer knives? I ask because i find it amazing that material is rough sawn and the figure is very pronounced.  I went back and bough a bunch of 5/4 curly maple, 8-10” wide 8’ long, it was dark again so ill have to get pictures this weekend.  Bought some that were 4” thick 4-5” wide 5’-6’ long.  Im gonna have to resaw a bunch of this

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The wavy grain won’t be “hard on the knives” but dirt I the grain would dull the knives faster. Just scrub with a vacuum brush first.

The problem with wavy grain is it’s more likely to tearout. When you get close to final dimension make very shallow passes or take it to someone with a widebelt sander.
 
IMO Maple is not that hard on knives. Dirt, gravel and metal certainly are though. If it is dirty and gritty give it a bit of a shower and dry it off. If you think that metal is a problem buy a metal detector. Other than that it should not be too bad. If it is super highly figured you could have some issues with tear out but that is just part of the journey with gorgeous wood. Just joint an edge so you can properly read the grain and make the best decision you can about feed direction. Then if the results are bad turn the board end for end and try again to see which way is better. You will learn fast.
 
BTW, I like Michael’s vacuum idea better than my “give it a shower” concept but you be the judge😊
 
Okay, now we’re going to need pictures!!!  You can see the figure on the rough saw boards???  (I believe you, but now I want to see what you’re looking at...before and after you plane it...pleeeeease!).  [smile]
 
Alanbach said:
Tough call without seeing it up close and personal. It’s really a judgement call. Modest warp is a lot easier to deal with than twist. Also if you are able to store the wood you buy in a climate controlled environment and get it stabilized before and after you mill it that will certainly help a lot. Sounds like you need to account for an above average quantity of waste but if you have the space and the savings are huge it is probably worth the risk.

BTW, you are not wrong about those issues being common in thick rough cut hardwoods but if you buy it commercially you can pick through it and cherry pick the pieces you want. Probably not as feasible in a case like this.

The good news is that if you buy a lot of this wood it is going to significantly improve your milling skills!

Thanks, i appreciate the advice.  But listen, yesterday i spent $250, today i spent $120, in the picture with the boards laying down you can see all the lumber i bought.  Its 100% curly maple or figured cherry.  Mostly maple.  In the picture with the boards standing up, thats a mixture of ash, oak, walnut, more curly maple.  Beneath all that small stuff you see laying down is a bunch of boards at least 8” wide, 8’ long and 15-20 boards 15” wide 10’ long.  If i can’t get my moneys worth out of all this then something is wrong.

Now granted there are certainly some boards that are in less than perfect shape, stains, a little rot, etc.  and the worst part is, this stuff has been sitting so long that what i thought were walnut boards was actually curly maple.  That much dust/dirt/grime has accumulated.  For the stuff that has stains, rot, or warped too bad, oh well.  But im not a production shop.  Im a hobbyist.  My name says ForumMFG but that was because when i joined this group thats who i was working for.  I have no idea why i picked that name.  As a hobbyist i have time to get these boards in the condition they need to be in.

ef7b91168d2b305ca8da3e0f7dc970a4.jpg
7005f0e39a53ee09e4bf369ff4d2bfd5.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Michael Kellough said:
The wavy grain won’t be “hard on the knives” but dirt I the grain would dull the knives faster. Just scrub with a vacuum brush first.

The problem with wavy grain is it’s more likely to tearout. When you get close to final dimension make very shallow passes or take it to someone with a widebelt sander.

This is a great idea, as i just said, it is so dirty.  What i thought may have been walnut was maple!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
RKA said:
Okay, now we’re going to need pictures!!!  You can see the figure on the rough saw boards???  (I believe you, but now I want to see what you’re looking at...before and after you plane it...pleeeeease!).  [smile]

Here you go, broke out a block plane, did a little sanding and put some odies oil on it.  Its amazing.  And i picked a board with the least amount of figure.  There is also some birds eye and what i call blister maple.  2nd pic is the birds eye with a little dirt on it.  Ill have to dig out the blister maple 

48d336a8779deb637b47d3ffd7e6f788.jpg
e47b6314004f447775279e1a700124e9.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Michael Kellough said:
The wavy grain won’t be “hard on the knives” but dirt I the grain would dull the knives faster. Just scrub with a vacuum brush first.

The problem with wavy grain is it’s more likely to tearout. When you get close to final dimension make very shallow passes or take it to someone with a widebelt sander.

I agree 100%...working with birds eye maple and even when I take a cut of only .010" using a straight knife planer, some of the eyes of the maple are ripped out and there are only voids left. At some point, I did the best I could with what I had and I then used a local service that put the birds eye maple through a Time Saver.

Maybe a helical insert planer would work better...just a thought.

The Time Saver approach however is still the best to provide a uniform surface and appearance.

I'd also warn against trying to finesse the surface too much with a planer. There were times when I looked at the surface and thought "maybe just one more really thin pass with the planer and everything will be perfect."  Only to find out I now had more eyes missing than the previous result.  [sad]
 
And by the way, in that pic of the curly, thats not a stain, its just the angle i took the photo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Cheese said:
Michael Kellough said:
The wavy grain won’t be “hard on the knives” but dirt I the grain would dull the knives faster. Just scrub with a vacuum brush first.

The problem with wavy grain is it’s more likely to tearout. When you get close to final dimension make very shallow passes or take it to someone with a widebelt sander.

I agree 100%...working with birds eye maple and even when I take a cut of only .010" using a straight knife planer, some of the eyes of the maple are ripped out and there are only voids left. At some point, I did the best I could with what I had and I then used a local service that put the birds eye maple through a Time Saver.

Maybe a helical insert planer would work better...just a thought.

The Time Saver approach however is still the best to provide a uniform surface and appearance.

Whats a time saver? Never heard of that?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top