Not sure if this will help but may be a point to consider.
Oil finishes need to penetrate for best results if for any reason it doesn't goo will lay on top.
My experience is not with Surfix but many a year back we put together a bar top of teak.
Sanded all per normal and applied tung oil finish per normal. We got goo.
We were early on in our experience (meaning not very knowledgeable) and learned that the supplied teak was apparently not fully dried. Since the wood was still fairly 'green', the sanding and heat generated let the natural oils come up in the wood acting as a sealant.
I'm not sure I recall exactly how we fixed it, may have sanded then refinished but the critical step involved was using a solvent (alcohol I believe) to mitigate the natural oils of the wood. Rub down the sanded surface with alcohol, let dry and applied the tung, better results. Apparently the solvent thinned and or removed the oils in the wood surface enough for the finish to penetrate.
Scraping the goo might also work then hit it with solvent but a test piece of same materials used should be tried first to see if it works.
One would think, however, that the goo would eventually dry off anyway but whatever causes the initial problems may have messed with the chemistry of the finishes involved.
We also had problems with prefinished lacquered stuff (not fully cured we believe) and trying to touch it up with polyurethane. Again sanding, solvent cleaning (for the poly) and using brush on lacquer to refinish worked.
We now do test pieces with intended finish to make sure.