Which sander to buy first! - First Post in the Forum

[Cypren]

Like I said about your test, you take one particular vac (an autoclean no less) and use it for one particular situation and then somehow extrapolate that to all Festool vacs. That's not how it works. I am talking about 4 different vacs over a 10 year period, working with them on an almost daily basis in every conceivable situation and they've had to handle almost any type of dust and debris out there. I know a lot better what these vacs can do then those test boys. And I am disappointed. I really like the features and form factor of the Festool vacs, but they just fall behind in suction.

Not all Festool vacs, just the CT series, since they all use the same motor and operating mechanism design and the only real differences are the size of the container and the presence or absence of the autoclean feature. (The shootout I linked doesn't specify whether or not they used AC in their clogged-filter test, but since a number of the vacs have the feature, I would assume they probably did.)

The CT 15, SYS, Mini and Midi all use different internals than the main CT series and I wouldn't expect performance characteristics to generalize between them.

The main reason I don't weight personal experience very highly when making pronouncements about the capabilities of tools is that it's too heavily confounded by other variables. The way you personally handle the vacuum, how often you change bags and filters, what grade of filter you equip it with, the kinds of material you use it on, the hoses you use; all of this has a very substantial impact on performance. I completely believe you that the Festool vacuums have performed poorly for you given the way you've used them. But if I may borrow your own criticism, you can't extrapolate that to everyone else in the world. And so I tend to go by objective measurements that have done their best to control for personal differences in usage when evaluating what a tool can do.

 

[Cheese]

Theres a lot of mentions about fitting a 150 pad on an ETS EC 125, but why cant you put a 125 pd on an ETS EC 150 ? surely its the same fitting, is it the size of the sander body? which would not affect sanding on flat surfaces.

Unfortunately, Festool uses 2 different sanding pad drive methods on the sanders. The ETS EC 125 utilizes a round drive with 2 flattened sides, while the ETS EC 150 adds 2 ears to the drive.

ETS EC 125 sander with round drive & 2 flats.

[attachimg=1]

LH = 125 pad    RH = 150 pad with 2 ears.

[attachimg=2]

 

[craigsalisbury75]

Theres a lot of mentions about fitting a 150 pad on an ETS EC 125, but why cant you put a 125 pd on an ETS EC 150 ? surely its the same fitting, is it the size of the sander body? which would not affect sanding on flat surfaces.

Unfortunately, Festool uses 2 different sanding pad drive methods on the sanders. The ETS EC 125 utilizes a round drive with 2 flattened sides, while the ETS EC 150 adds 2 ears to the drive.

ETS EC 125 sander with round drive & 2 flats.

[attachimg=1]

LH = 125 pad    RH = 150 pad with 2 ears.

[attachimg=2]

thanks for the explanation, i guess i dont need the 125 pad, but the option would have been nice

 

[mrboult]

In reality I feel one could easily carve out a 125mm pad to fit the ETS EC 150.

But, I do remember (maybe incorrectly) something about the bolt not being long enough for the taller 125mm pad. No actual experience with the 150 machines myself, I only have the 125 sander.

Happy Christmas all. X

 

[Imemiter]

It's with a significant amount of shame I say I bought a Bosch GET75-6N today.  There were a number of reasons for this and I really appreciate all the feedback I have gotten from everyone.

I like that sander! I was hovering on the brink of a Rotex until Bosch talked me off the ledge with a $50 off day.  [big grin] Now that I've used it back to back with an RO125 I'm not at all unhappy with my choice.

 

[hammy]

It's with a significant amount of shame I say I bought a Bosch GET75-6N today.  There were a number of reasons for this and I really appreciate all the feedback I have gotten from everyone.

I like that sander! I was hovering on the brink of a Rotex until Bosch talked me off the ledge with a $50 off day.  [big grin] Now that I've used it back to back with an RO125 I'm not at all unhappy with my choice.

That's great to hear, thanks!  Just as a point of interest I found an RO 150 at a local dealer and asked how much it was... they said $1,340 ..... holy mark ups!

 

[Jesse Cloud]

I make furniture.  I have a shop with a jointer and planer, so I never have to sand really rough wood.

Whats important to me is speed of getting the job done (not having to go back to remove curlicues mainly) and clean operation.  I have the 6 inch 150/3.  Remember that the area of a circle is pi times the radius of a circle.  A 5 inch disk has a 2.5 inch radius, so r squared is 6.25, where the 6 inch disk radius is three so r squared is 9 - a 44 percent improvement in area and in speed.

I find the dust extraction excellent, which saves a lot of cleanup time and sandpaper.

A variable speed vac is great if you often sand light things, eg thin panels. 

I do have a Rotex I use for sculpting.  It gets about 1 percent of the usage the RTS does.

If I had to sand stuff upside down, I would definitely want the lightest sander on offer.

Just another data point, your mileage may vary.

 

[Michael Kowalenko]

Hello everyone. Based on all of this discussion, today I purchased the ETS EC 125/3 and a 150 hard pad. I am looking forward to using this sander in either the 5” and 6” mode as needed. However, I cannot loosen the bolt to remove the installed 125 pad. Hopefully it won’t need Festool service. Comments? Help?

 

[AlexThePalex]

Hello everyone. Based on all of this discussion, today I purchased the ETS EC 125/3 and a 150 hard pad. I am looking forward to using this sander in either the 5” and 6” mode as needed. However, I cannot loosen the bolt to remove the installed 125 pad. Hopefully it won’t need Festool service. Comments? Help?

It is normal it is tight from the factory. Just try to hold the pad securely and use more force with a wrench. If you have an impact driver that will help greatly.

 

[afish]

I do not know but is it possibly a left/reverse threaded bolt?

 

[hammy]

Just an update... I’ve cancelled my Bosch order, after some reflection on all the feedback I think I’m going ets ec 125! Still mulling over the vac option.

 

[Michael Kowalenko]

Hi Hammy, from Edmonton ... almost on the other coast and a few time zones away. Another reason I went with the ETS EC 125/3 and 150 pad is that I already have the CT48E. As it turns out, buying that item back then with the OF1400 made this decision today easier, as I wanted to capitalize on the great dust extraction of the system.

 

[xedos]

Just an update... I’ve cancelled my Bosch order, after some reflection on all the feedback I think I’m going ets ec 125! Still mulling over the vac option.

It would appear analysis paralysis has set in. 

Just get the EC125 and a MINI.  Be done with it and get onto making stuff.  You can always return either or both within 30days if you don’t take a shine to them. 

 

[mino]

Not so.

I’ve been sanding edges with my 125 for more than a dozen years. But I do plan to buy the edge guide because it will make the task easier, and probably turn out better.

The point of the guide - as I see it - you can "make" or correct an edge where there is none proper and avoid "unmaking one" via uneven pressure etc. All that even on a finished piece.
One would need a stationary disc sander to get the precision the guide can provide via other means.

 

[hammy]

Just an update... I’ve cancelled my Bosch order, after some reflection on all the feedback I think I’m going ets ec 125! Still mulling over the vac option.

It would appear analysis paralysis has set in. 

Just get the EC125 and a MINI.  Be done with it and get onto making stuff.  You can always return either or both within 30days if you don’t take a shine to them.

I think you are right, I just need to go buy one and get it over with.

 

[hammy]

Hello everyone. Based on all of this discussion, today I purchased the ETS EC 125/3 and a 150 hard pad. I am looking forward to using this sander in either the 5” and 6 mode as needed. However, I cannot loosen the bolt to remove the installed 125 pad. Hopefully it won’t need Festool service. Comments? Help?

That's great Michael, at least one of us listened to the good advice here!  I'm pretty sure I'm going to do the same.

 

[SoonerFan]

Hello everyone. Based on all of this discussion, today I purchased the ETS EC 125/3 and a 150 hard pad. I am looking forward to using this sander in either the 5” and 6” mode as needed. However, I cannot loosen the bolt to remove the installed 125 pad. Hopefully it won’t need Festool service. Comments? Help?

That's great Michael, at least one of us listened to the good advice here!  I'm pretty sure I'm going to do the same.

If I were you I would do it.  I have the ETS EC 125 and it is a great sander. Only caution is many of us did not stop at one sander.  I now also an RO125 and a DTS400 and am looking at a cordless for quick jobs. 

 

[Alanbach]

[member=74584]hammy[/member] - ok one last comment since you have switched back to the ETS EC 125. I would continue to strongly encourage you to bite the bullet and choose one of the Festool CT vacs. I have given you my opinion in a couple of posts here so I will just wrap it up by going back to your original post. You said that you did not like sanding and you wanted to find something that would make you like it. I have been here and on other forums for years now and I have heard from countless people (including myself) about how they always hated sanding until they got a Festool sander and CT vac combo. The sander you have chosen coupled with a Festool vac will almost certainly change the way you feel about sanding. If that is still what you want I suggest that you pull the trigger. You can thank us later. Yes, it is crazy money for a sander but it works crazy good and like I said earlier once you have the vac you will be ready for all those other Festools that are going to buy in the future.

 

[Cypren]

I'll note that if the CT series is too expensive for your tastes, the Makita VC4210L offers similar benefits to the CT 36 AC HEPA (41 liter capacity, similar airflow/suction, HEPA filtration, passthrough power with automatic activation, filter autoclean, and even systainer docking) at about 2/3 of the cost. What you give up is integration with the rest of the Festool system: the fitted, twist-lock hoses, the Bluetooth integration with cordless tools, and the accessories like the boom arm that Makita doesn't offer. Depending upon your use cases, this may be a pretty worthwhile tradeoff to save $300, even moreso if you already have Makita power tools that are compatible with their own Bluetooth module system.

 

[AlexThePalex]

I'd just like to add that you can use any vac with your sander, you don't need to have a Festool vac if you don't want to spend money on that. Before I had my first Festool vac I used my home vac for years.