Can a plunge cut saw truly replace a table saw?

For cutting sheet goods down to size, I don't think i would ever consider using a table saw again.  It is so much easier to, as some one mentioned above, bring saw to wood instead of wood to saw.  I can cut to size right on my truck without unloading, or suspending sheets from tailgate to saw horse, setting up with blocks of wood on ground, or other methods and do it safely and without lifting.  There was a time when i could carry full sheets of 3/4 ply up a ladder to second or third floor (non windy days only) with some trouble, but do-able.  i have problems today trying to manage 1/4 ply to move anywhere.  I won't even try to cut full sheets any other way but with track saw.

Second reason for choosing tracksaw over table saw is lack of space in my shop. To cut any board, whether dimension lumber or sheet goods, it it will fit in my shop, I can stabilize and cut it to dimension using my track saw.  To cut wit a table saw, i need two to four times the space of the wood being cut.  Cross cutting of long dimension lumber is impossible.

I do a lot of, mostly infact, small projects.  most recently, i used up a lot of small scraps to make several sets of bookends.  Many of the pieces ended up being cut to 3/4 inch widths and some as narrow as 3/16 inch.  Most of the pieces ended up being less than 6 inches in length. If i were taking all of those parts from full lenght boards, or even 2 feet long boards, i would agree it to be much easier with table saw.  But i was using scraps of lumber, many less than 6 inches in length.  I could probably have done it with a table saw by making some sort of jig or sliding table to do it safely.  With the ATF, and some mistooks along the way, i finally worked out a method to make such cuts with out error and do it safely.  It did take time to work it out, but it is doable, and in my estimation, a whole lot safer than with a table saw.  I have since thought of another method that might be even better.  I still have not gotten comfortable with using the parallel guides, but i am still working on that method.  Others have a lot of praise, and i can see the advantage.  i just have not gotten there yet.

The last advantage I see with the ATF (track saw) over table saw of any size is portability.  In good weather, I sometimes set up a couple of horses and a sheet of ply or MDf outside and do most of my cutting out in the sunshine.  I can't do that with the Tablesaw.  I don't even think i could manage to move a DW bench saw (don't think of the model number right now, is it 745?) up out of my cellar shop.  that would put me out of biz for a week.
Tinker
 
People keep saying about bring the saw too wood is easier, what a load of crap, how did the wood get there? Magic? Sorry but if you have a big workshop witha big slider i wouls opt for a tableaw everytime, wood out the van or off the ack the straight to saw
 
Deansocial said:
People keep saying about bring the saw too wood is easier, what a load of crap, how did the wood get there? Magic? Sorry but if you have a big workshop witha big slider i wouls opt for a tableaw everytime, wood out the van or off the ack the straight to saw

For some of us old guys, just getting the wood off the truck is as good as it gets.  Getting it to the saw is a completely new project.  [big grin]
 
Deansocial said:
People keep saying about bring the saw too wood is easier, what a load of crap, how did the wood get there? Magic? Sorry but if you have a big workshop witha big slider i wouls opt for a tableaw everytime, wood out the van or off the ack the straight to saw

I don't think you wood try getting a sheet of plywood or MDF into my shop more than once.  Not even a half sheet is very much fun.
Once in there, you would have lots of joy trying to maneuver it onto a table saw.  I don't think that is possible.

As for me, i find there seems to be a lot more substance than there uster Be to almost anything I try to pick up and move to >>> anywhere [unsure] My ATF seems to be as much as I care to move.  A lot more fun than a sheet of ply 8)
Tinker
 
One bit of convenience I get out of my TS55 is that I can take it to the lumber yard and cut my ply there and then to suitable size to fit my car and not pay the $10/cut they bill you for chopping boards on their slider saw. They don't mind me borrowing a bit of electricity and throwing my own 2x4's under the sheet of ply in their warehouse.  [tongue]
 
Reiska said:
One bit of convenience I get out of my TS55 is that I can take it to the lumber yard and cut my ply there and then to suitable size to fit my car and not pay the $10/cut they bill you for chopping boards on their slider saw. They don't mind me borrowing a bit of electricity and throwing my own 2x4's under the sheet of ply in their warehouse.  [tongue]

Here is to show you how different it can be in different places.  The place I buy my cabinet grade woods won't let me use a handsaw to cut my purchased products after paying for them even in the parking lot due to insurance restrictions. 

Peter
 
Peter Halle said:
Here is to show you how different it can be in different places.  The place I buy my cabinet grade woods won't let me use a handsaw to cut my purchased products after paying for them even in the parking lot due to insurance restrictions.

And the corollary to that is if you decide to let them cut it for you, expect the cut dimensions to be off by as much as 1/2".

I have to believe some wood merchants put the most inept person they can find on the cut saw. It frequently results in you having to buy more wood to fix the problem.
 
"No" , Its a pipe dream .The Track saw is great at what it does ,but ripping 1/64" off of a narrow piece of flexible stock ? I dont think so ...
 
Back
Top