Festool or Dewalt planer?

adsjoin

Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2014
Messages
71
Abit of advice please  I currently have the Dewalt 26500 which has served me very well. I'm thinking more towards dust control here, btw. I mainly use the planer for trimming doors. The question being do I change to a festool planer? Either the hl850 or ehl 65 eq? I have the ct midi which I could connect to, but how good is the dust control going to be inside a clients house? Any comments welcome, thanks.
 
The ehl65 is perfect for you. With the midi I often trim doors in houses with pretty much dust free results
 
[size=12pt]

I have a 65 and it has served me very well in building our house. Tasks have included wall frame planning, back planning architraves, trimming doors, stair building, and building counter tops.

It has excellent depth adjustment, is light for high and overhead work, and hose can be connected to either side.

As for dust, chip collection see the following about 1/2 way in - fantastic.

 
Get the "65".
I did 7 doors last week in a clients house fitted in existing frames so lots of adjustments required.
Flat was on third floor so plugged "65" into the midi and set up bench in living room and planed a lot.
The "65" will plane 4mm as advertised but it's best used sensible and perfect for those little adjustments of 0.5mm and back bevels even while doors are hung.
No mess whatsoever.
Dust extraction is superb, you even notice the difference on your clothes.
Client was Amazed and there is no way I'd get 7 hung in a day if I was in and out all day plane outside.
You won't regret it, I haven't.
Scott
 
I have the 850 and the DC is excellent. No need to worry about using in a finished house.  The D36 hose is probably a better choice than the D27. Also have you considered the TS55 or TS75 for trimming doors?

Seth
 
Thanks guys, looks like I'll be getting another addition to my small but growing "Festool" family  [big grin] Seth, I got the 55 already which I use on the straight trims off doors, sink & hob cuts outs and loads moorrrreee (top piece of time saving kit that is) Again thanks to all for your experienced answers, appreciate it very much  [smile]
 
Adsjoin
              If you are mainly trimming doors or the back of worktops etc. where your likely to be hitting staples and other rubbish ,the extra cost of Festool blades could be prohibitive compared to standard TCT reversible ones .
              I Would recommend a Bosch(4mm)  planer . Festool 27 or 36mm hoses are a straight fit to either side , output is switched from right to left by moving a lever.
Much quicker to use when changing planing direction or depending on where you put your door down .
Martin
 
vajoiner said:
Adsjoin
              If you are mainly trimming doors or the back of worktops etc. where your likely to be hitting staples and other rubbish ,the extra cost of Festool blades could be prohibitive compared to standard TCT reversible ones .
              I Would recommend a Bosch(4mm)  planer . Festool 27 or 36mm hoses are a straight fit to either side , output is switched from right to left by moving a lever.
Much quicker to use when changing planing direction or depending on where you put your door down .
Martin

I would steer clear of the bosch model I have had experience with:
http://www.woodworkforums.com/showthread.php?t=181170
Bosch GHO 26-82 Professional Planer - Snipe!
 
Another vote for the 65 for doors here ...

I've also just eBayed my 92mm Hitachi planer ... it did a great job, but the mess and the noise ... so I'll be getting my little 65 a bigger brother.                       
 
vajoiner said:
Adsjoin
              If you are mainly trimming doors or the back of worktops etc. where your likely to be hitting staples and other rubbish ,the extra cost of Festool blades could be prohibitive compared to standard TCT reversible ones .
              I Would recommend a Bosch(4mm)  planer . Festool 27 or 36mm hoses are a straight fit to either side , output is switched from right to left by moving a lever.
Much quicker to use when changing planing direction or depending on where you put your door down .
Martin

Another vote for the Bosch - I connect mine to a MIDI and have no problems with dust at all.

Here in th US, a new model with switchable port is ~150$. I bought mine secondhand nearly a decade ago for 60$ and have used it (professionally) ever since.
 
Kev, I too love my Hitachi, especially since it will plane a 2X4 in one pass.  I solved the dustup by taking a Sears vac attachment (have tons of extras as price wise and results were great... just incredibly loud... use a Fein now), heating it with a 
heat gun, forming it to the dust exhaust port and attaching with epoxy.  Not as efficient as Festool but certainly reduces the cloud factor.
 
rst said:
Kev, I too love my Hitachi, especially since it will plane a 2X4 in one pass.  I solved the dustup by taking a Sears vac attachment (have tons of extras as price wise and results were great... just incredibly loud... use a Fein now), heating it with a   
heat gun, forming it to the dust exhaust port and attaching with epoxy.  Not as efficient as Festool but certainly reduces the cloud factor.

You have far more patience than me [big grin]

I remember the first time I used the Hitachi planer ... had a very sticky door, so I took it off and made a couple of passes. Thought to my self "maybe a bit more, but I'll try it for fit". I'd taken so much off in those couple of passes that it sailed straight by the lock jam !!! That's when I developed a lot of respect for that planer.
 
Before getting a new planer, I would first get the 36 mm hose (if you haven't got it already). (for planing I prefer the non AS version, because it's lighter and not as stiff)

I have a makita 1100 planer, which is a model that exists for a VERY long time, and I also have the optional bevelguide for it. I really like the planer, and because I mainly use it for doors, the weight doesn't bother me. It does have a longer sole than most other planers, which is a good thing for precision, but not so good to fit it inside a systainer.
link

A few years ago, right after festool changed to the T-loc systainers, one of the dealers had a clearance sale of demotools. I bought the boom arm for my ct22 and a HL850 planer at a discount price. I also got the bevelguide for it, and a spare blade.

The first time I used the planer I was at first impressed at how smooth and quiet it was, and I liked the quality of the bevelguide (which only bevels in one direction, which is handy for squaring (no need to use a spuare to set it, just put it at zero), but I use the bevelguide on my makita in the other direction. (there's a modification that can be made to have it bevel further, but for me that wouldn't work out, because then I still can't see what I'm doing because the blade is at the other side of the planer.)
I also like the soft start and the blade brake, and the possibility to make very deep rebates.
It also has a little parking foot, and the dustport can be reversed (features which most other planers also have, but my makita doesn't; the parking foot doesn't matter much when you have a bevelguide installed).

Now for the dislikes: the throttle style depth control is harder to control while keeping the planer in balance than the knob style (while hanging over the door to see a scribed line, due to the throttle handle, I can't stand on the other side of the door). And the major dislike: SNIPE (first I thought this could easily be remedied by downloading the supplemental owner's manual and following the directions, but there isn't one for the HL850)

There wasn't a major improvement in dust collection (which was already excellent with the makita), or smoothness of the cut (as long as I finish with a shallow pass with the makita).

I didn't go for the 65 because there isn't a bevelguide available for it (and the position of the handle doesn't look ergonomically comfortable to me.)

edit: I think I'll send the festool planer in for repair, allthough it was already five years old when I got it, they did register it for the 3 year warranty on the date of the sale; maybe festool can fix the snipe problem
 
WOW, I feel like I've come out of the dark ages! First job with my new ehl 65 today. Covered everywhere with dust sheets as I would normally do with the Dewalt planer (always get a fine dust coming through the chip bag). Fitted 4 doors with the 65 connected to the midi. NO CHIPPING OR DUST THAT I COULD SEE ANYWHERE!!!    FESTOOL RULES, Still in disbelief to be honest as I never thought it was going to be that good, even after watching videos and listening to you guys. THANKS for all your help  [big grin]
 
im saving for a new planer as my old bosch one died recently due to knackered bearings. also its depth control mechanism had somehow jammed up so its doubly dead. deffo considering the greater expense for a ehl65 compared to a light weight bosch planer like what i used before or like what my mate at work has.
 
Back
Top