bobfog said:
Peter, given the statements made above, it does appear that your reviews have become a little more commercially driven and contrived. You used to have a mantra that your reviews were only for products you would recommend to your very best friend and you weren't on anyone's payroll. Additionally they seemed to once be more targeted at things you owned, but these days they seem to be predominantly about either donated or loaned products. Is it the case that you've diluted your recommendations away from that mantra?
I remember you gave a glowing review of the UJK router table only to never see it again in your workshop.
It's not a criticism, I am a fan of your products (I own Parf Dogs and the Parf Guide System) but I am interested to know if you are now compensated for your reviews?
Hi Bob
The "Golden Rule" is still there and has and never will be broken. If I cannot recommend a product or a process to my very best friend then there is no video.
In order to make this series of videos I have spent over £250, paying the full retail price (no favours at all). The items that are on loan will be returned when I finally complete the series.
If my work was commercially driven then you would see videos about rubbish stuff that appears on some of the large box shifters web sites (I am not talking about Festool at Screwfix !). I have, more than once, been offered a complete workshop full of power tools just to make a couple of videos. I now set a 3 month time limit on kit that gets sent to me which fails the Golden Rule and never gets collected. Some goes to recycling and some gets given away to chaps only too eager to give it a go.
I treat all of this as "Commercial in Confidence" otherwise my subjective view of what is good or bad would dominate the whole aim of The New Brit Workshop. I know several people who will be reading this now who have had kit rejected by me but I doubt whether they will be prepared to join this debate now.
Let me give you some very simple stats from the last financial year...
I have sent out over 1500 sets of plans, free of charge, to people wanting to make things that I have shown in my videos. I have answered every question placed on my YouTube channel and acknowledged every comment - that is over 25 messages or emails a day.
In order to make some of the things that you see I get some support. The two classic cases are Coldene Castors who have helped me with every nutty design that I have created for the "Mobile Workshop" concept. The other is Accuride who have also helped in that area. Without their support there would have been no videos in that series. My only income is from the advertising on YouTube and if anyone thinks that is generous then I challenge them to have a go and find out.
My Festool videos are made with kit that I have bought or borrowed. Festool UK have helped a lot but they do not invite me to do this or that. I suspect after this they will not bother answering any more of my emails. I badger them for whatever I think people want to see next. Look at the timing of the MFS video that I did. Festool did not give a stuff about that product but boy was there some interest from here on the FOG and tons more on YouTube. Look how much later my KS60 videos were compared to others.
The payroll bit next...
I have only been paid for one video. That video in not on my YouTube channel and has never been shown (to my knowledge) here on the FOG. The girls involved were very kind and promised to say nothing to anyone.
Next the UJK Router Table...
Space in my workshop is at a premium due mainly to the camera kit and the need to have a "studio" area for most of the filming. Somethings have had to go. The UJK Router table (better fence than the CMS-OF, very accurate but not so good dust collection) had to go. Next to go will be the X-Carve CNC which will be advertised for sale very soon.
Finally,
I work 7 days a week. I have spent many thousands on camera and sound equipment (again, no special deals and full prices paid). My aim now is to give something back - to help other people. If I spent the same amount of time pushing trollies at the local supermarket I would, by now, have made enough money to buy every bit of Festool kit that they make plus a car or two and have the extra time on my hands to enjoy it all.
Peter