FS-WA Angle Stop & Guide Extension Combo - Impromptu Parallel Guide?

TinyShop

Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2017
Messages
661
[member=76829]ThunderBeest[/member] [member=71573]Eggy Toast[/member] [member=77132]grim_lokason[/member] [member=71478]FestitaMakool[/member] [member=61254]mino[/member] 

For folks who own the FS-WA (577040), did any of you also purchase the "Guide Extension" a.k.a. FS-WA-VL (577041)?

Anyone unfamiliar with it can watch Frank rather embarrassingly demo it here:
=5s

Anyways, the Angle Stop paired with a single Guide Extension, at a package cost of between US$195 and US$250 (depending on which side of the pond you reside), would appear to offer some repeatability in not only cutting material to length (as shown rather awkwardly in the above video) but also processing sheet goods (in lieu of a set of parallel guides) as demonstrated a couple of years ago by fellow FOG'er [member=4105]tjbnwi[/member] using TSO kit:


Now, the graduations on the stock guide extension are limited in length to 45" (1160mm) - the graduations don't extend all the way to the end owing to the design of the flip stop (which uses up a lot of real estate aft of it) - so that's a limitation.

[attachimg=1]

And another limitation is that there's no allowance for producing rips narrower than about 17" (430mm).

[attachimg=2]

However, these limitations aside, it looks like this combo could be put to use in a pinch as an impromptu single arm parallel guide. I wonder if Festool realizes the potential here and if a Version 2.0 might be in development that expands on the idea? Good opportunity to redesign the Festool parallel guides which are starting to look a little prehistoric in the face of all the competing versions now in the marketplace.

Finally, for anyone contemplating adding a second length of extrusion: at first it occurred to me that one could potentially expand the capacity by adding a second length of guide extension. But then I realized this won't work given how the flip stop relies on one of the two t-tracks on the underside of the extrusion, the same t-tracks that the connectors use. Bummer that. If the flip stop instead relied on a t-track located on the top face of the extrusion then this idea would have legs.

Nonetheless, I figured I'd share this potential use for anyone who hadn't yet thought of it.
 

Attachments

  • Capture3.JPG
    Capture3.JPG
    31.8 KB · Views: 2,032
  • Capture2.JPG
    Capture2.JPG
    15.3 KB · Views: 1,914
TinyShop said:
Anyways, the Angle Stop paired with a single Guide Extension, at a package cost of between US$195 and US$250 (depending on which side of the pond you reside),

On this side of the pond, you have to start by finding a European dealer that will ship to the United States; the FS-WA in still NAINA.  We still only have the FS-KS available here.
 
squall_line said:
TinyShop said:
Anyways, the Angle Stop paired with a single Guide Extension, at a package cost of between US$195 and US$250 (depending on which side of the pond you reside),

On this side of the pond, you have to start by finding a European dealer that will ship to the United States; the FS-WA in still NAINA.  We still only have the FS-KS available here.

Where's there a will there's a way. This is actually easier than many may think. Happy to point folks in the right direction. PM or email me....
 
[member=64030]TinyShop[/member] thanks for the ping!

Just realized that the extension is just €40 over here which is a bargain* compared to the various PG sets.

Where I can see this useful is for MFT-style mounting where the extension can act as a one-side fence. It should be better in this role than the TSO PG side as it is much stronger.

Overall, before testing, I know I will like it. But IMO it is not a real alternative to PGs. It is too heavy for that use. But for one-sided stop or for MFT cutting station fence ... that is another matter. The added bulk should actually help there. Challenge accepted!

*Never thought I would use Festool and bargain in one sentence. Eh.
 
[member=64030]TinyShop[/member] - Thanks for the heads up!

Yes.. I bought the lot.. that would be; added the extension to the kit. As mentioned it has a reasonably price, and I figured exactly the same as you. It could serve as an quick and easy PG replacement when cutting the not so extremely critical cuts. I don’t think it’ll replace parallel guides. But when squaring up the protractor or setting an angle for angled cuts it’s very valuable.
Sort of like the FSK rails, but now you’re only limited by the length of rail you have, and TS saws and HK saws can be used.

I did a lot of panel cutting lately, this was with the FSK 670 rail, and I loved the ease and repeatability when I found the ideal angle and set it on the FSK stop. It made the job go so much faster and with ease. One measurement; and cut. Same can be done here, only now one can have a set length (with limits) or slightly varying lengths with quick adjustments.
Sometimes it replaces the mitre saw, sometimes it does what the mitre saw cannot do.

Say you need a slope/scribing cabinets or similar, once set you have repeatability in a pinch. Referencing from an edge. This would equal multi measuring and marking most of the time without this set.

The extension is beefy and heavy. Not tested; but I imagine you can flip it upside down and utilise the t-track from above instead, maybe tack a self adhesive ruler/tape on this side? (I can test this). It shares the same track as the ones on the rails. So it can have multiple uses: Extension for a track to an edge for clamping where the rail isn’t long enough and you don’t need to cut the whole width of a panel. A very hefty ruler (Needs an additional tape for this) with a ruler stop? A straight edge…
A clamped down parallel guide for cutting without rail (It’s 800mm long). Straight aid for glueing?
There must be more..  [big grin] Still, now already enough excuses to get one? [cool]
 
TinyShop said:
Finally, for anyone contemplating adding a second length of extrusion: at first it occurred to me that one could potentially expand the capacity by adding a second length of guide extension. But then I realized this won't work given how the flip stop relies on one of the two t-tracks on the underside of the extrusion, the same t-tracks that the connectors use. Bummer that. If the flip stop instead relied on a t-track located on the top face of the extrusion then this idea would have legs.

Exactly, my first thoughts too. Then again, the extension would have to be used upside down, and a bridge would have to be fabricated to connect it to the rail. Maybe TSO can make some add on’s?  [smile] It may cannibalise their PG’s, but mostly it would be even more pin point accuracy setting up any angle that are not 90°.
It would be to heavy and tedious to compete with PG’s that way.
So, expanding capabilities is the most likely outcome of some aftermarket add-on’s
 
[member=71478]FestitaMakool[/member] - thanks so much for providing your insights! I, for one, look forward to your forthcoming testing. :)
 
Well, there’s not really much exciting one can do.

I’ll add a few photos, as seen, the extension is made from the exact same profile as the bottom of the FS-WA. It CAN be attached upside down, a slight shift in height (1/2 a mm or less) is the only drawback.

It’s easier to use an existing parallel guide to attach to the rail. A long support arm connecting to the rearmost part of the extension and to the rails upper t-track for added accuracy and support might be good. As Shinwas freehand cutting squares, here’s two, but there are several:

[attachimg=1]

[attachimg=2]

 

Attachments

  • 5D45CF19-D1F1-45FD-919A-E8A357FBF324.jpeg
    5D45CF19-D1F1-45FD-919A-E8A357FBF324.jpeg
    120.1 KB · Views: 1,682
  • C7C371D0-72F4-4D74-B2CB-16275645DEBB.jpeg
    C7C371D0-72F4-4D74-B2CB-16275645DEBB.jpeg
    294.7 KB · Views: 1,696
Some images:

Notice some shifting in alignment where the parts meet
[attachimg=1]

The parts that make up the stop
[attachimg=2]

With a stop from Kapex wings (needs a bigger nut and a shorter screw)
[attachimg=3]

Offset, top pointer to bottom (in the area of 37mm)
[attachimg=4]

You really need a square that can reach these contact points marked in blue. This square was the only that I could fit [huh]
[attachimg=5]

[attachimg=6]

Both parts seen from below
[attachimg=7]
 

Attachments

  • 01F105DB-C509-4F66-ACEF-BA5229314F52.jpeg
    01F105DB-C509-4F66-ACEF-BA5229314F52.jpeg
    103.1 KB · Views: 1,671
  • D86E95B5-A71B-4CEB-B453-3CAB5A7F7A74.jpeg
    D86E95B5-A71B-4CEB-B453-3CAB5A7F7A74.jpeg
    145.8 KB · Views: 1,739
  • E731F9B6-0F86-48EE-8CF3-97ED2E8004EC.jpeg
    E731F9B6-0F86-48EE-8CF3-97ED2E8004EC.jpeg
    116.9 KB · Views: 1,703
  • C2D511C4-565D-4E6E-9A7E-7184312333F9.jpeg
    C2D511C4-565D-4E6E-9A7E-7184312333F9.jpeg
    135.9 KB · Views: 1,674
  • 4E93B7F5-360A-4A03-B6ED-F270FAE5351D.jpeg
    4E93B7F5-360A-4A03-B6ED-F270FAE5351D.jpeg
    91 KB · Views: 1,667
  • 8A8ADEB7-C038-40B7-9AE1-A7A5CAE321D0.jpeg
    8A8ADEB7-C038-40B7-9AE1-A7A5CAE321D0.jpeg
    91.2 KB · Views: 1,651
  • F7BE4BF7-4599-442E-BFBE-291B69B8F83D.jpeg
    F7BE4BF7-4599-442E-BFBE-291B69B8F83D.jpeg
    87.8 KB · Views: 1,690
[member=71478]FestitaMakool[/member] - very interesting. So, from your comments it would appear that this tool doesn't offer high levels of precision and is more intended for certain limited site tasks. Thus I'm struggling to see its usefulness in  light of other more versatile solutions. Maybe others will chime in to offer their real world experiences using both tools.
 
Well, no. But it is a great alternative to a fixed 90°

I see it as an alternative or alongside FSK rails with the HK saws wich I much enjoy.
The fact that not every work situation can be executed with only 90° and/or parallel cuts
makes this for all those other occasions. Repeatability at the angle demanded, and with a plunge saw. Or a HK for that matter. It’ll do 90° when squared, but it’s alongside and an addition to the squares and parallel guides for the rails.

To say, there’s not a particularly good reason for me to fit a zero clearance insert for my mitre saw at this point. It would have been chewed up quite quickly..
 
FestitaMakool said:
For a pro or a fan, yeah, a good complement.

But the real value is IMO for a hobby user.

The FS-WA is the ideal component of a minimal tool chest for a hobby user. I.e. someone who will have the TS, an FS/2 and the set with the FS-WA which includes the self-aligning connectors and one will be good to go for *any* task. Just add $20 engineer's square for calibrating and there you go!
 
mino said:
FestitaMakool said:
For a pro or a fan, yeah, a good complement.

But the real value is IMO for a hobby user.

The FS-WA is the ideal component of a minimal tool chest for a hobby user. I.e. someone who will have the TS, an FS/2 and the set with the FS-WA which includes the self-aligning connectors and one will be good to go for *any* task. Just add $20 engineer's square for calibrating and there you go!

That’s exactly why I bought it Mino. As an advanced hobby user, mostly doing carpentry and finishing work. I look into what helps me, preferably a lot more than just one thing. The things that for me makes my “production” a lot easier are probably worth it. You could get just the FS-WA, it’s very reasonable as a stand alone angle adaptor. To me, I wanted and needed the Systainer, the screw clamps, the hose and cord guide, the rail stop and the rail connectors - the lot.

I’ve had great use for it already, today a setup dadoing with the OF 1010 window finish trim, on a MFT that’s absolutely not flat, using Festool’s original rail brackets, protractor and fence. Adding to this two rail stops (had one from before..) the dados are coming out square and nice, even when pushing the router slight uphill haha [big grin]. One window takes time and effort, nothing is by todays standards or square.. cutting down speciality casings tongue to match 70-80 year old grooves. That’s the name of the game.
Truth be told, I’m really enjoying the flexibility one some of my Festool’s all round use, in particular the CS 50

Most useful and maybe cheapest tool that saves the day, it’s often my everyday hero:
A Stanley carpenters plane, that can shift the blade out to the very edge, and even plane with a second knife on the nose, to reach right into the corners:
[attachimg=1]
 

Attachments

  • E8261978-16EB-4174-BD11-CE34A6FC351B.jpeg
    E8261978-16EB-4174-BD11-CE34A6FC351B.jpeg
    336.5 KB · Views: 1,546
I just received the FS-WA-VL and am a bit underwhelmed by it to be blunt about it!

On the positive side, the extension bar is quite hefty and relatively cheap compared to many Festool accessories (good $/weight ratio if this matters  [wink]), but I do find the design lazy and the use case quite limited due to shortcuts taken during its design.

First off, with the 2 connecting bars in place and centered between the FS-WA-VL and the FS-WA, the stop can't go below 560mm (one has to pretty much remove one of the two connecting bars to reach the 430mm graduation (putting in effect all the weight of the hefty extension on just one of the connecting bars, and weakening the assembly).

Each of the connecting bars is the second half of the FSV/2 (engravings make this clear!), meaning that there is some play and no guarantee that the extension guide is in line with the FS-WA. Had Festool used both parts of the FSV/2, this problem would not exist (but it would have cannibalized sales of the FSV/2 I guess).

As others have indicated there is no simple way to reverse the extension bar+flip stop and use it on the far end of the board to be cut (one would have to make a stop extension (plus extend the cursor and add some sticky tape ruler) to make this work (There are holes in the clunky stop which might help with this, but it's probably easier to start from scratch with a new stop design)

The stop itself (which is fixed and not of the 'flip stop' kind) has some wobble, meaning that it's not very consistent once moved. It is also fairly thick (Great when cutting materials 1 1/2" thick or more, but not very convenient for thin sheet).

Had festool machined a T-slot on top of the extension bar, the bar would have been lighter and the full range of the graduation could have been easily used (and it would have been easy to design a stop which flips or could work when the extension is on the far side of the workpiece). One could also dream of a way to store the allen wrench (but I might be asking too much).

Now there might be some creative ways to use this beefy profile for applications it wasn't originally intended for... and that might be its saving grace
 
German MHM have just released a review of the FS-WA. It’s in German,hope our German friends can help us out with a short resume [big grin].
My German bist sehr schlecht.. but I can follow so I got that he was fairly pleased  [smile]

MHM
 
Back
Top