Reuse or Replace Dowels in Chair Refinishing?

[onocoffee]

I'm refinishing a court chair from the 1920s for my dad. Got it stripped and taken apart. It was assembled using dowels and I'm wondering if I should replace them with new dowels or just clean them up and reassemble? The chair also uses slotted screws in certain spots - like to secure the arms and the seat. Most of them seem to be in good condition. Should they be replaced as well?

Thanks!

 

[luvmytoolz]

I'd definitely be replacing the dowels, especially if the chair had even the tiniest bit of wobble.

I would also generally change the screws if not for function, then for aesthetics.

 

[ChuckS]

For restoration, I always defer to Tom Johnson's practice (Thomas Johnson Antique Restoration on YT) when in doubt.

Unless the dowels (or tenons) are in poor condition, loose fit if not replaced, out of round, or the old glue cannot be properly removed, I'd prefer to keep and use the original dowels for two main reasons: 1) maintaining the authenticity 2) avoiding unnecessary work (e.g. removing or drilling out the old dowels).

If you clean a dowel hole and result in a bigger hole, you may need to redrill the hole and plug it -- which is more work. So be careful when cleaning the dowel holes for glue residue.

The same applies to screws and hardware as keeping the original character (sometimes, including minor blemishes) is desirable or important for an antique piece. Use the original materials where possible unless they would result in a weaker structure or strength.

For restoring antique pieces, consider using Old Brown Glue or the like, which would make future restoration effort (e.g. 50 years later ) easier instead of yellow glue. However, don't shy from using yellow glue or even epoxy glue or new wood if that's the right glue or material to use for a fix.

 

[ChuckS]

Btw, do you have the habit of signing and dating your work? If so, also consider attaching a label (with your name and date on it) to the underside of the chair to acknowledge your restoration effort. I did that when I helped fix a coffee table for a neighbor whose father built it while a school boy in the UK.

Names on label altered. The label was created by the neighbor at my suggestion. The coffee table now is owned by one of his sons, the maker's eldest grandson.

 

[jeffinsgf]

I'm refinishing a court chair from the 1920s for my dad. Got it stripped and taken apart. It was assembled using dowels and I'm wondering if I should replace them with new dowels or just clean them up and reassemble? The chair also uses slotted screws in certain spots - like to secure the arms and the seat. Most of them seem to be in good condition. Should they be replaced as well?

Thanks!

If the old screws are usable, I would use them. Nothing screams "refurbished" as much as Phillips or Torx screws in a vintage piece...furniture or machinery.

 

[ChuckS]

Good point.

 

[waho6o9]

Keep original items and clock your screws.
Nice strip job of the old finish, that is a lot of work.
Good advice above using brown glue and signing your good work.
Rock on

 

[onocoffee]

I’ve managed to break some of the screws into the arms. What’s the best way to extract these?

 

[luvmytoolz]

I’ve managed to break some of the screws into the arms. What’s the best way to extract these?

Carefully drill through a pilot hole in some metal sheet (to keep it from wandering) into the centre of the screw top a bit, and use proper screw extractors is the only way I know to remove broken screws without causing further damage.

 

[ChuckS]

One approach: