Lincoln said:
No, you're not unreasonable. I'd want a new saw, not a fixed one.
Actually he is very much unreasonable.
The OP
chose to take advantage of the all-inclusive
service coverage
instead of returning within 30 days and purchasing another unit.
That is equivalent to telling Festool "
please repair my tool if possible".
Now, on topic:
[member=81325]accavre[/member] if you are unhappy how Festool tried - to their best ability - to repair a tool you asked them to repair, then you still have the 30-day return option and can send it back once you get it shipped to you. No questions asked.
ChuckS said:
...
If you ask me, I'd prefer the one that's consistent, reliable and overall satisfactory, not the one that swings from one extreme to another. I thank my lucky stars that all my Festool machines (including the "infamous" EB Kapex) have been working well since day 1. The last thing I want is to have to send any one of them in for service!
Absolutely with your overall point. However, here that is not applicable really.
The main complain seems to be a new saw was not shipped when the customer requested his saw is repaired. If anything, there was a basic misunderstanding of a difference between "sending for service" and "returning the merchandise". Whatever caused that misunderstanding, the only thing Festool could do better here was actively
push the customer to a 30-day return which, frankly, would be weird.
Then, as for the communication, the clerk could have a guidance of "if within 30 days product is sent in, and is confirmed faulty, offer a replacement for a new one (which may take longer than the repair)". That is about it. It would not have any material effect - the customer would get the exact same value back - but it can provide some "feel good" psychologically as a "sorry".
Also, from OP comments it seems to be he is conditioned to the low-quality products shipped by most other brands and operates from there.
Thus not understanding that a saw with a faulty part replaced is *not* a "refurbished saw" as far as the actual physical state of affairs goes. Festool tools are MADE TO BE SERVICED which not the case with most other brands ...
That is an equivalent to stating that a car with a replaced ECU is a "refurbished car. It is not. And neither is a saw serviced after three cuts. It is a "serviced" product. Something very different. Albeit in the Festool case - thanks to how high a standard they have for "refurbished" there are not many practical differences.
I will add other brand issue. I literally had a brand new router spindle overheating under no load (apparently a bad bearing). I had the manufacturer service center send me away with a comment "yeah, it is a bit hot, when it fails (ed. in my face ?) sent it in and we will replace or fix". I still have that in writing ... now that is some bad service, some would argue even illegal. Not just some miscommunication like here.