Carvex 110v My thoughts on.....

Troll

Member
Joined
May 9, 2007
Messages
88
I purchased the 110v top handle saw in June of last year, I only use it primarily for sink and hob cut-outs.  It's the model with the strobe light that can't be adjusted.  Most of my tools are Festool and overwhelmingly I'm extremely pleased with them.  Unfortunately, in my opinion this jigsaw is a big disappointment.  I know the strobe light has now been changed, so criticism of this must be taken in context.  I simply find that the constant flashing of this light extremely irritating to my eye sight to the point I don't look at it now if possible.

The saw release mechanism is a big step backwards for two reasons: firstly, you now have to remove the splinterguard to eject the blade; and secondly, you can only eject the blade if it has stopped in the 'up' position.  The blade release slide only activates the release mechanism on the plunger rod when it's 'up', this is extremely irritating and poorly thought out. And as an aside the thumb lever on the slide mechanism keeps falling off.

I really can't work out what the 'automatic' setting is all about.  It seems to have no real purpose and simply engineered and fitted because it can be.  My saw 'stalls' when turning tight corners and in automatic mode. What's wrong with the user setting the saw's maximum speed and the saw simply having the standard feature of automatically compensating for increase loads? Perhaps I'm missing something and someone will explain.

Subjectively, the saw feels more 'plastic' than the trion, especially the top handle.  I'd also prefer a more chunkier handle, It's a bit thin for me (but that's an individual thing).  Another annoying point that is specific to the UK 110v version (and applies to a few Festool tools) is that it's extremely difficult to shut the systainer with the bulky110v  plug.  You end up with the lid of the systainer bulging out.

Anyway in summary I can't recommend this saw and I think your money would be better spent on a top of the range Bosch at probably half the cost.  I've sent it off for repair and hopefully Festool UK can modify the strobe light and the other faults otherwise it's on ebay.

Troll
 
Well, it's no secret I hate my Carvex  [mad]. I will send it back AGAIN to see if they can make it any better !
 
Hi there are very few people that have anything good to say about the carvex . I bought the mafell p1 cc and am very pleased with it.

I picked up a carvex in a dealers and thought that the handle be more suited to a boy of 10 years it is sooooo thin yuck

the Uk 110v plug is an issue for most tools,cases regardless of manufacturer there is just not enough room [sad] I have the same issue withe the mafell in a sys one there is one way to get it in thats it.... [sad]

I would not be asking for a repair on the carvex I would be asking for a refund. [mad]
 
Trust me, if I thought there was any chance of getting my money back I would snap at it.  I have the barrel grip but my issue is with the blade guide.  The blade just won't stay straight.  Glad I didn't sell my Makita.

You guys in the States, don't wait for it, get a Makita or Bosch.
 
Alan

Send it back to TTS!!!

Mine is absolutely fine, I prefer it over the Trion.

If TTS wont play ball email Festool Germany, I did that a couple of years ago and the issue was resolved within a couple of days!

Oh to have Festool USA customer service ethos in Europe!
 
not sure why so many jumped to get the carvex. I only use jigsaw to rough cut the waste out and cope skirting. dont see the need for all the silly bases
 
Deansocial said:
not sure why so many jumped to get the carvex. I only use jigsaw to rough cut the waste out and cope skirting. dont see the need for all the silly bases

Totally agree, never got them and dont see the need for those additional bases
 
I agree about the bases, I really can't see that there can be anyone who has a real purpose / use for all the various base configurations.  Sometimes I think tool designers / engineers can lose sight of the real world of work and design features because they can and not because they have any real benefit to the end user.  It's the same with the strobe light.  What real benefit does it give to the end user that a permanent light doesn't? 

All I want from a jigsaw is to cut a 90 degree cut in worktop, and for me to be easily able to follow any given line.  I made the mistake of buying the carvex without trying it and in all honestly there was a certain appeal in owning a complete set of Festool.  That was a mistake, and as I've said in previous posts, as the inventor of the jigsaw I think it's one tool that Bosch consistently makes better, or almost as good, as anyone else.  And at a cost considerably less than Festool.  Yes I know I still bought the Festool, I let my heart rule my head!

As an aside, is the Mafell's jigsaw up to the mark when using standard blades, as against the expensive special blades designed specifically for the Mafell?

Troll
 
Troll said:
I agree about the bases, I really can't see that there can be anyone who has a real purpose / use for all the various base configurations.  Sometimes I think tool designers / engineers can lose sight of the real world of work and design features because they can and not because they have any real benefit to the end user.   It's the same with the strobe light.  What real benefit does it give to the end user that a permanent light doesn't?  

All I want from a jigsaw is to cut a 90 degree cut in worktop, and for me to be easily able to follow any given line.  I made the mistake of buying the carvex without trying it and in all honestly there was a certain appeal in owning a complete set of Festool.  That was a mistake, and as I've said in previous posts, as the inventor of the jigsaw I think it's one tool that Bosch consistently makes better, or almost as good, as anyone else.  And at a cost considerably less than Festool.  Yes I know I still bought the Festool, I let my heart rule my head!

As an aside, is the Mafell's jigsaw up to the mark when using standard blades, as against the expensive special blades designed specifically for the Mafell?

Troll

I have used the mafell with a festool normal blade for curved cuts it cuts as fast and as tightly as you like with a perpendicular cut no downside at all
go find somewhere to check one out

 
Chaps,

A properly re- built and upgraded Carvex is a top drawer jigsaw.

If you are unhappy with your saw get it back to TTS ,get them to sort it. When it comes back still not up to scratch , go through the process of listening to their lies and excuses  and send it back again. When it comes back, still a load of rubbish, Get on to Festool Germany and kick up HELL.

I have an early Carvex that I eventually sent to the guy that designed the thing. He over saw a complete re build and upgrade of the machine did the QC and test cuts himself and couriered it back to me. It was like a different machine  just brilliant

TTS UK are ( cant type what i think here). You will have to fight to get it sorted and unfortunately the TTS UK repair shop just cant do it , you need to get it to TTS Germany and their technicians can.
 
I used the carvex for the first time today... whose idea was it to put them stupid lights on the front??? trying to follow a line on a worktop and couldn't see a thing... Can you turn them off ??????

John...
 
Hi John

I thought they were supposed to improve vision by making the blade appear still do you find it of no help? it sounded like a great idea

is it a late model? because I thought the user could turn the light off on later the versions
 
The light seemed to reflect of the worktop so the line disappeared .....I have no idea if its a new model, its the 14v version.. It looks like the blu-tack will be coming out to cover the lights  [big grin]
Also when notching the back of the cabinets (chipboard) it looks as though you are throwing glitter in front of the saw......

John..
 
Hi foggers I've got the body grip type. First one I had broke 3 time so when festool sent me a new one I wasnt expecting any change. But was I wrong it's a great jigsaw best I've ever had and I've had a few.
 
luke1984 said:
Hi foggers I've got the body grip type. First one I had broke 3 time so when festool sent me a new one I wasnt expecting any change. But was I wrong it's a great jigsaw best I've ever had and I've had a few.

I sounds like they're getting the issues worked out, which is promising!
 
I've had this saw for a couple of weeks and have done some cutting with it, only curves and cut outs. This is one example http://tinyurl.com/6wogqjp not complicated and it didn't matter to be precise but it served as a "testing ground" for Carvex. So let me skip to the point  :)
Before Carvex i had Bosch 1591 D handle. I am reading that a lot of people are complaining about their tool this is my experience with it:
A) about ejecting the blade - didn't have any problems with it. The rod was always at top so no problem there
B) strobe light - ok my old bosch didn't have any light and when i turn normal (not strobe) light on carvex it is extremely difficult to concentrate on the cutting line because everything is flashing and can not follow nothing. Strobe light on and  [eek] [eek] [eek] how could i ever cut anything with the old jigsaw. For me it is the best feature on this saw and gives a perfect view of the cutting line. Festool  [thumbs up] [thumbs up] for this
C) i do have some questions for the repair service and soon as I finish the things i have started it is going to the dealer for inspection - if it is a feature you must know about it because it is well not very good. Auto mode. I am cutting something thin that doesn't require a lot of power and my carvex starts slow than speed up and then slows down again and then after a few second speeds up again. That is not good and is more annoying that a real problem

Oh yea and a question for festool. Why didn't yout put green color on the leaver that is ejecting the blade  [big grin]

So all in all for now my jig saw is very good for me and I am among small group of people on this forum that actually loves his saw  ;D
 
Neth ,
I have a Festool PDF that gives instructions on how to turn the lights on and off, have no clue how to post it on the forum, will try to pm it.
John
 
Back
Top