I MUST HAVE ONE!!!!

Jonhilgen said:
I'm going to spray paint a few thousand of these bad boys red and sell them for 50.00.  They're one handed, and you can use them with your left or right hand!  And all you need is a pencil (for an extra 10.00 bucks I'll throw one in).

It looks well made, and very nice, please don't get me wrong.  Just a little overkill when a 3.00 compass scribe is faster, easier, and smarter...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Scribe_compass_A.jpg

Jon

This would be the "right-hand" model shown...Left-hand is a small additional charge.    [big grin]
[attachimg=#]
 
RonWen said:
Jonhilgen said:
I'm going to spray paint a few thousand of these bad boys red and sell them for 50.00.  They're one handed, and you can use them with your left or right hand!  And all you need is a pencil (for an extra 10.00 bucks I'll throw one in).

It looks well made, and very nice, please don't get me wrong.  Just a little overkill when a 3.00 compass scribe is faster, easier, and smarter...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Scribe_compass_A.jpg

Jon

This would be the "right-hand" model shown...Left-hand is a small additional charge.    [big grin]
[attachimg=#]

Nah!

http://www.medfordtools.com/fastcap/accuscribe/accuscribe2.jpg

http://www.medfordtools.com/fastcap/accuscribe.html

Much more better  [big grin]
 
Kev said:
RonWen said:
Jonhilgen said:
I'm going to spray paint a few thousand of these bad boys red and sell them for 50.00.  They're one handed, and you can use them with your left or right hand!  And all you need is a pencil (for an extra 10.00 bucks I'll throw one in).

It looks well made, and very nice, please don't get me wrong.  Just a little overkill when a 3.00 compass scribe is faster, easier, and smarter...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Scribe_compass_A.jpg

Jon

This would be the "right-hand" model shown...Left-hand is a small additional charge.    [big grin]
[attachimg=#]

Nah!

http://www.medfordtools.com/fastcap/accuscribe/accuscribe2.jpg

http://www.medfordtools.com/fastcap/accuscribe.html

Much more better  [big grin]

I do have one of those -- the only issue is making certain the thumb nuts are tight enough so the size doesn't change mid-task.
 
Jonhilgen said:
You mean like this [big grin].  Was thinking the same thing.

I was thinking more like this...  [poke]

7486992938_b918f69505_c.jpg


[tongue]

btw, your brick scribing motivated me to do this with the tile.  So where do I send the bill for the few hours of my life I won't get back? 

Kev said:
To me it seems targeted at matching floors and walls - think it'll do those well

Not trying to sound over simplistic, but a pencil taped to the top of a wooden block works just as well for those applications.

Its a nifty gizmo, but I don't think its worth $80, or even $10 for that matter.    
 
Seems very over priced for what it does. BUT for a gloss kitchen plinth I could see it being useful to limit splintering when cutting.
 
Deansocial said:
Seems very over priced for what it does. BUT for a gloss kitchen plinth I could see it being useful to limit splintering when cutting.

But it must be a fair price, the top of the page says "A Christian owned corporation"..... [blink]
 
fritter63 said:
Deansocial said:
Seems very over priced for what it does. BUT for a gloss kitchen plinth I could see it being useful to limit splintering when cutting.

But it must be a fair price, the top of the page says "A Christian owned corporation"..... [blink]

Religious affiliations aside, solely from a material/ manufacturing aspect the price doesn't seem crazy for a piece of machined anodized aluminum. I have purchased anodized motorcycle parts for more money and they don't even have moving parts.   

In terms of functional value to me, $80 for this tool is a lot.   
 
Hence why I said overpriced for what it does. I done care how cheap some thing is made, if it cost $1 to make but sold for $100 but made my job quicker easier and more precise I would buy it because it has value.
 
Vindingo said:
The size of the base seems like it would really limit the amount of detail you could pick up. 

No scribing brick or stone with this tool...

A simple compas will never beat scribing something like brick work in detail  but  to me this tool seems handy for scribing skirting and plinths etc where you are not wanting to go into to much detail scribing all you want is just a nice constant flow which is better with a wider base. 

JMB

 
jmbfestool said:
Vindingo said:
The size of the base seems like it would really limit the amount of detail you could pick up. 

No scribing brick or stone with this tool...

A simple compas will never beat scribing something like brick work in detail  but  to me this tool seems handy for scribing skirting and plinths etc where you are not wanting to go into to much detail scribing all you want is just a nice constant flow which is better with a wider base. 

JMB

Vindingo said:
...but a pencil taped to the top of a wooden block works just as well for those applications.

I understand that some people like shiny bits and expensive tools, but this one doesn't do it for me. 

 
1 of those carbide inserts screwed to a block of wood would work the same too if you need the scoring function, I think to many people need gadgets to do their job now when simple stuff works fine
 
Vindingo said:
jmbfestool said:
Vindingo said:
The size of the base seems like it would really limit the amount of detail you could pick up. 

No scribing brick or stone with this tool...

A simple compas will never beat scribing something like brick work in detail  but  to me this tool seems handy for scribing skirting and plinths etc where you are not wanting to go into to much detail scribing all you want is just a nice constant flow which is better with a wider base. 

JMB

Vindingo said:
...but a pencil taped to the top of a wooden block works just as well for those applications.

I understand that some people like shiny bits and expensive tools, but this one doesn't do it for me.   

I know I read that but like you said!  Some people (ME) like shiny stuff! 

BUT 

still a block of wood is time waisting if you only had to  make ONE maybe still annoying though that you have to go and rip/cut a piece of wood to the depth you want for scribing to place your pencil on top to then tape it down in place and if you have various depths to scribe you end up making a few blocks.  Easier having a tool like that you can just turn it to required depth you want. 

JMB
 
Deansocial said:
1 of those carbide inserts screwed to a block of wood would work the same too if you need the scoring function, I think to many people need gadgets to do their job now when simple stuff works fine

shut up you
 
Vindingo said:
Jonhilgen said:
You mean like this [big grin].  Was thinking the same thing.

I was thinking more like this...  [poke]

7486992938_b918f69505_c.jpg


[tongue]

btw, your brick scribing motivated me to do this with the tile.  So where do I send the bill for the few hours of my life I won't get back? 

Kev said:
To me it seems targeted at matching floors and walls - think it'll do those well

Not trying to sound over simplistic, but a pencil taped to the top of a wooden block works just as well for those applications.

Its a nifty gizmo, but I don't think its worth $80, or even $10 for that matter.    

Showoff.  Nice work though!  Glad I could bring some misery to a fellow Fogger.

Jon
 
Back
Top