new mft/3 anybody use t track mounted miter gauge?

NEW2FES

Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2012
Messages
96
Ok, finally ordered my first Festool and sorry to say not 100% impressed/ I lurked around here so I knew the miter fence was questionable but for the money was expecting more. Yes it can be set for accuracy but the repeatability is not there without fiddling or checking.

I need more set and cut accuracy as others also have posted so on to the first addition. I have an Osbourne t track miter gauge for a table saw and figured why not router a t track slot and use the Osbourne gauge. It is free and would hopefully eliminate all the flex and non repeatability of the Festool one.

Anybody ever mount a miter fence like this????

Thanks
 
Check out qwas dogs.  There is another user who also makes dogs to attach rails, forgetting his name right now.

Just realize that the fence is only half of the equation leading to possible inaccuracies.  I find the more important variable to control is your plunge and cut as the rail also has some play.

Maybe I am just lazy, but when I want dead accurate I use my table saw.  For cabinet building the MFT is plenty accurate.
 
I find that with the MFT/3 properly set up that it is very accurate and repeatable.  It did take some adjusting and there are a lot of things to tighten down.  At Festool training class they walked through an order of how to set things up and adjust and since I have followed that method everything has checked out fine for me...now I only square things if I take the protractor off and put it back on...otherwise, it stays adjusted.  You can look at the process on Festool TV on YouTube or a call to Festool Service and they can walk you through the adjustments.   

Scot
 
I realize that it will feel a bit like a "gotcha", but buying at least a pair of the qwas dogs will enable you to square your table up easily.  The MFT top is CNC bored to pretty much a dead perfect grid - you can use the qwas dogs to calibrate the rail and the fence to be square.  It takes me all of two minutes (tops) to go from having the fence and and guide rail detached to setup and perfectly square.
 
I have no problems at all with the accuracy (squareness) of my MFT 3 - it is a great piece of kit and an essential tool if you do work away from base. It would be a good idea to get it set up properly in the first place so get some 20mm dogs (from Qwas in North America or Intelligent Workshop in Europe) and follow the routine in either Paul Marcel's video or my video review of the dogs in the 'Other Tool Review' section here on the FOG.

Yes, there is a new dog design on the way which will improve accuracy, repeatability and ease of travel. It will be a couple of weeks more before they are annouced.

Peter
 
I have the Qwas and the problem isn't setting it up it is the flex and movement of all the fixtures. I am always lost when someone says their's works perfect when in design it would be impossible??

If you set the miter gauge up to perfection then lift, remove a piece of wood, set in a new one, you will show a difference. I know it is wood and everybody's idea of accuracy is different. Simply set the gauge then grab the opposite end of the bar and you can flex it about 10 degrees. If you put pressure of the short end you can also move it.

The miter assy attaches with pressure from a clamp that has rubber on it that also causes flex and inaccuracy.

The idea to use a t track miter gauge is they are adjustable to keep movement to a min. You have a hardened steel bar moving within a aluminum track that has adjustability to remove any slop. Once that is set the assy itself has again almost no deflection.

I just do not understand why at this price point the miter gauge isn't more "SET AND GO" without constant checking. There is no argument here it is just fact. I like think if more were honest instead of cheerleading there would be a better product. I am sorry but if I just picked this up at Hardor for $250 I would say fine but this is a $600 folding table without accys that work properly and accurate.

I like this site and don't want anybody to get the wrong idea, I call it as I see it.

 
NEW2FES said:
I have the Qwas and the problem isn't setting it up it is the flex and movement of all the fixtures. I am always lost when someone says their's works perfect when in design it would be impossible??

If you set the miter gauge up to perfection then lift, remove a piece of wood, set in a new one, you will show a difference. I know it is wood and everybody's idea of accuracy is different. Simply set the gauge then grab the opposite end of the bar and you can flex it about 10 degrees. If you put pressure of the short end you can also move it.

The miter assy attaches with pressure from a clamp that has rubber on it that also causes flex and inaccuracy.

The idea to use a t track miter gauge is they are adjustable to keep movement to a min. You have a hardened steel bar moving within a aluminum track that has adjustability to remove any slop. Once that is set the assy itself has again almost no deflection.

I just do not understand why at this price point the miter gauge isn't more "SET AND GO" without constant checking. There is no argument here it is just fact. I like think if more were honest instead of cheerleading there would be a better product. I am sorry but if I just picked this up at Hardor for $250 I would say fine but this is a $600 folding table without accys that work properly and accurate.

I like this site and don't want anybody to get the wrong idea, I call it as I see it.

You're right, as a miter gauge it doesn't compare to an Incra etc.
Just think of it as a pivot point with some ballpark angle positions that you have to dial in for your purpose.
Once you have the angle set you should clamp the fence down if you plan to make more than one cut.
 
The 'Parf Dogs' will go a long way to solving this problem. The prototype sets will be made very soon.

Peter
 
NEW2FES said:
I have the Qwas and the problem isn't setting it up it is the flex and movement of all the fixtures. I am always lost when someone says their's works perfect when in design it would be impossible??

If you set the miter gauge up to perfection then lift, remove a piece of wood, set in a new one, you will show a difference. I know it is wood and everybody's idea of accuracy is different. Simply set the gauge then grab the opposite end of the bar and you can flex it about 10 degrees. If you put pressure of the short end you can also move it.

The miter assy attaches with pressure from a clamp that has rubber on it that also causes flex and inaccuracy.

The idea to use a t track miter gauge is they are adjustable to keep movement to a min. You have a hardened steel bar moving within a aluminum track that has adjustability to remove any slop. Once that is set the assy itself has again almost no deflection.

I just do not understand why at this price point the miter gauge isn't more "SET AND GO" without constant checking. There is no argument here it is just fact. I like think if more were honest instead of cheerleading there would be a better product. I am sorry but if I just picked this up at Hardor for $250 I would say fine but this is a $600 folding table without accys that work properly and accurate.

I like this site and don't want anybody to get the wrong idea, I call it as I see it.

Nothing wrong with you saying that at all.  I am curious to know what you're doing with your MFT that you are pushing hard enough on whatever it is that you're cutting that you'd set the fence off by that much.  Also, if there IS that much flex, why not simply put a clamped stopper behind it as mentioned?  I agree with you that it is an expensive piece of gear, but you also have to bear in mind that it was designed to be portable - and to make it rock solid would mean that it would be too heavy to be practical to move.  So, you get a table that will give you very accurate references, you just need to take the extra step of securing them to the point where it's solid enough for whatever you're doing.

As a functional example, I've cut shims of varying widths on each end to true up the subfloor of my house.  I had to cut well over 500 of them, and rarely more than 2 or 3 at a time were the exact same dimensions in a given batch.  I used dogs to attach a rail to two tables, and a 2x4 that I had planed down to give me a straight reference point.  I slid that under the rail and butted it up against the dogs.  From there, I had shims that I had cut, and would insert them as needed.  Now, I could shove on the 2x4s that I'd trim down as hard as I wanted to, and nothing was going to budge ever.

Here are some pictures, hopefully it'll help a bit.  As far as the fence goes, it's the same idea - just have to secure it to meet your needs.

tGVDOh.jpg


That's one of the spacers

ZdUwFh.jpg


That's the table setup

IuH5vh.jpg


That's one of the "better" transitions between sheets of ply in terms of elevation changes

2qBX9h.jpg


And that was the subfloor before a bit of sanding to do some smoothing here and there.  Flat, level, and solid - three things it certainly was NOT before I started.  There was no way I would have been able to do that in any reasonable period of time without the tables and (qwas) dogs.

Finally...

V4EIf.jpg


That's the hallway and one of the bedrooms having the first coat of poly applied.  Every room on that floor needed the subfloors corrected, with some areas having a drop of more than 2 inches over 8 feet.

Anyway, long-winded and rambling way of getting to the point I suppose, but it is what it is.  Ripping down 2x4s in random lengths to glue and nail under ply or on their own onto old wavy subfloor was not a gentle task, and there was a lot of slamming of pieces to ensure that they were firmly in place before cutting.  Yes, there were some mistakes, but they were all due to failures relative to things such as simple math.

 
From the amount of flex you say your fence has, I'm fairly certain you didn't install the black thingy to secure the other end of the fence.

You can see it near the end of this video (it is installed at about 5 min into the video)
link
 
I also just purchased the track saw and am having the slope issue. I have it dialed in perfectly square, however when I change the angle I am roughly a half of a degree off. A real pain when cutting picture frames. Also I am having an issue with a "D" shape when cutting the stock. Not sure why this is occurring. Does anyone have any ideas?  Oh and the fence does have some slope to it. If i use the lock down at the end of the fence that too is throwing me off from time to time either pushing or pulling the fence back. Any ideas on this as well?

 
Kayaker145 said:
I also just purchased the track saw and am having the slope issue. I have it dialed in perfectly square, however when I change the angle I am roughly a half of a degree off. A real pain when cutting picture frames. Also I am having an issue with a "D" shape when cutting the stock. Not sure why this is occurring. Does anyone have any ideas?  Oh and the fence does have some slope to it. If i use the lock down at the end of the fence that too is throwing me off from time to time either pushing or pulling the fence back. Any ideas on this as well?

As far as the stop on the end of the fence, I think that the key is to tighten to the fence first and then to the table profile at square.  If you do it the other way around you can throw things off when you tighten to the fence as it will pull or push the fence in or out -- the fence will flex and the rail on the MFT is stronger where the clamp is tightened.

Scot
 
This is a $600 table it should not need anything to work properly. I like the bench otherwise but it just is annoying to have to make excuses for it. I am well aware of the outward clamp and yes it will lock it in place but is awkward at best. The design of the miter gauge needs work. There are just too many clamping points that cause the flex and misalignment.

The internet is a very powerful forum. I bet Festools sales have gone up 75% from internet use as the Brands name has been wide spread as people always seek what is supposedly the best. I am the kind that does not mind spending the money as long as the item works, end of story. I do not want to build this or that or I would have just built myself a table.

By saying something works and knowing it is an issue just hurts everyone as the Co will not make changes and it creates dissatisfied buyers like myself. They can develop a miter gauge that works out of the box especially at this price point. Festools are great tools but I did not buy them to look at them and polish them. It should work and I hope someone sees this and redesigns it so it works better in the future.

I will correct to my liking but again shouldn't of had to at that price point. $600 for a folding table.
 
I at one time was extremely frustrated and upset with my festools and the MFT in particular. I couldnt get the damn thing square for the life of me. I watched the videos, talked to the tech support on the phone I was pizzzed

Until  went to a end user class, went through the set up with the instructor. My issue was a I didnt have a known good square for squaring up the guide ail and fence. When I realized what was happening, It was a ephinany the light came down fro heaven and I heard the angels sing.

I can now set my MFT and square everything up  faster then I can roll out my table saw, plug it in and plug in and attach my dust collector.

I suggest going to your brick and mortar festool dealer if he cant help you, get the number of the tech rep and meet him and he will learn ya everything you need to know.

Festools are a different way of doing things you have to change your mind set to the "festool way of doing thing" If that makes sense.
 
NEW2FES said:
This is a $600 table it should not need anything to work properly. I like the bench otherwise but it just is annoying to have to make excuses for it. I am well aware of the outward clamp and yes it will lock it in place but is awkward at best. The design of the miter gauge needs work. There are just too many clamping points that cause the flex and misalignment.

The internet is a very powerful forum. I bet Festools sales have gone up 75% from internet use as the Brands name has been wide spread as people always seek what is supposedly the best. I am the kind that does not mind spending the money as long as the item works, end of story. I do not want to build this or that or I would have just built myself a table.

By saying something works and knowing it is an issue just hurts everyone as the Co will not make changes and it creates dissatisfied buyers like myself. They can develop a miter gauge that works out of the box especially at this price point. Festools are great tools but I did not buy them to look at them and polish them. It should work and I hope someone sees this and redesigns it so it works better in the future.

I will correct to my liking but again shouldn't of had to at that price point. $600 for a folding table.

Amen, I feel the exact same way about my mft/3.
 
Then it would be time to use the return policy.

deBeaupre said:
NEW2FES said:
This is a $600 table it should not need anything to work properly. I like the bench otherwise but it just is annoying to have to make excuses for it. I am well aware of the outward clamp and yes it will lock it in place but is awkward at best. The design of the miter gauge needs work. There are just too many clamping points that cause the flex and misalignment.

The internet is a very powerful forum. I bet Festools sales have gone up 75% from internet use as the Brands name has been wide spread as people always seek what is supposedly the best. I am the kind that does not mind spending the money as long as the item works, end of story. I do not want to build this or that or I would have just built myself a table.

By saying something works and knowing it is an issue just hurts everyone as the Co will not make changes and it creates dissatisfied buyers like myself. They can develop a miter gauge that works out of the box especially at this price point. Festools are great tools but I did not buy them to look at them and polish them. It should work and I hope someone sees this and redesigns it so it works better in the future.

I will correct to my liking but again shouldn't of had to at that price point. $600 for a folding table.

Amen, I feel the exact same way about my mft/3.
 
In reply number 12 the statement was made "it should not need anything extra". The "fence rail clamp" (black thingy) is not an extra, it should have been in the MFT package. It is there to secure the free end of the fence.

The fence is over 3' long, the primary connecting point is close to the guide rail. That gives you a lever of about 2'. The engineers knew this could be a problem and supplied the fence rail clamp. Would you use a table saw fence without both ends being clamped to the saw rails???? Think about that flex.

The first thing you should do with the fence rail clamp is take it apart (don't loose the spring). Relocate the upper clamp section to the hole that moves the knob farther from the rail. Set the rail, slide the fence rail clamp in position, as previously mentioned, snug the clamp to the rail with the knob, now snug the clamp to the table with the lever. Neither have to be tightened, just snugged.

The above will eliminate any flex in the rail. Both "ends" are now secure to the table.

Tom
 
No sense in being frustrated, just call Festool tech support.
They'll dial it in for you and address your concerns.

Personally, I use rail dogs and qwas dogs as it's quicker for me.
Sometimes I attach the blue Rockler  t track rails to make multiple
cuts.

I like the idea of using a t track and Osborne miter gauge as well.
Maybe make a "V" and put the t track on it, that way you can use the
width and length of the MFT3.  The V will fit in the extruded aluminum
on the outside of the MFT3.
 
I bought the quas dogs and they do make it easier to get a true 90 between the fence and guide rail. I use them to put the fence exactly 90' from the guide rail they square the guide rail to the fence. Its dead nuts
 
I have to agree with NEW2FES. The MFT3 fence system has way to much flex in it. It drove me crazy trying to make square cuts on it. After months of messing around with it, got mad and drilled through the fence and bolted it down. Well that warped the fence. Ended up pitching the fence and making one out of a old delta sliding table fence. Cuts are dead on now and can have table much closer to wall. As for table being portable, really?
 
Back
Top