I must not have been clear, I think the cube will affect the dust collection hugely especially on saws that do not have the in shroud extraction of the Kapex. Most saws rely on the dust being ejected by the blade into a crude collection gizmo at the rear and underneath the blade shroud. Certainly that is the method that Bosch have used. For this to work in any fashion at all it relies on a clear path through the fence opening back to the debris collection point.
I would be interested in dust sampling measurements with and without the cube to see the difference. Mitre saws can be very indiscriminate on dust debris ejection and it requires very powerful dust extraction along with good shrouding to overcome the problem. keep in mind that the debris you can see are not the problem t is the sub micron dust you can't see that has the health effect. As good as it is the Festool answer to dust extraction on the Kapex is primarily aimed at the visible debris issue and not the fine sub micron dust emissions. In every video I see with the Kapex if the light and camera angle is right fine dust can be seen being sprayed into the air. It has the best dust collection but the bar is set very very low.
[/quote]
Hello, Mini. Yes, I understand. Were you able to test? I got the impression that you were going to mock up a comparable device and test. Maybe I misunderstood.
When giving my opinion about the DC, I wasn't thinking of other saws--only the Kapex. In regard to the "Shouldn't make much of a difference," my point was when the blade/saw was fully extended forward, in front of the fence, with the dust collector shroud in front of the fence too. I don't see how the Cube would make much of a difference with that part of the cut. Once the blade is pushed back toward the fence, once the shroud is above or behind the Cube, that is where the difference in DC will be made. However, as you mentioned, if the micro dust (which no miter saw is fantastic at collecting) is the issue, I would almost think that the Cube would be beneficial/better than no Cube, since it would help to keep the micro dust in a lower position as opposed to shoot it out the back, shooting upward, into a big plume. (If working outside, out the back would be better, but if in a shop, probably not).
I'm hoping that others post on here about the DC results of the Cube. As noted, my DC has still been great when compared to other saws. When the dust hits the Cube, it largely shoots up, into the shroud. More specifically, to a large degree, the dust shoots into the ZC channel, which is the upward shape of a blade and channels directly up to the shroud.
I will make the disclaimer that I'm not the dust collection king. I bought my Kapex because it's a fantastic tool, and I'm sure I have lots of room to improve. Before the testing of the Cube, I didn't even hook up my Kapex to a vacuum, because my cuts on it were few and the dust shot into an area easy to clean up.
Good conversation. I'd love to hear what others have to say about the DC with the Cube.