Anyone made a wooden exterior door using the domino?

Les

Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2007
Messages
487
I am making a wooden door for the exterior of a old log cabin which has "odd" size dimensions. It was built in the '30's mostly out of found material.

Would you use dominoes for the rail and stiles and tongue and groove for the panels?

TIA
 
Les, I believe Eiji made an exterior door with Domino tenons.  I'm not sold on using the Domino here.  It's just not much work to make large loose tenons joints for one door. 
 
Brice:

If I remember correctly, Eiji made really big loose tenons and cut the mortise with a router. Did he also use a Domino for a door? Maybe he'll chime in.

Tom
 
Tom Bellemare said:
Brice:

If I remember correctly, Eiji made really big loose tenons and cut the mortise with a router. Did he also use a Domino for a door? Maybe he'll chime in.

Tom

Yes, I remember seeing pictures of the door you're referring to.  I remember reading about someone making a door with the Domino, like I said, I think it was Eiji.
 
I seem to remember the same thing, Brice. I just can't remember if it was Eiji or someone else.

I think my memory of the door we are likely both remembering is so strong because it and the work that accompanied it were stunning.

Tom
 
I know of german carpenters, which did entry doors with the domino,
but they were using Sipo dominos instead of the beach standard version.
As to my knowledge, Sipo is very similar to Mahagoni.

kind regards, Mike
 
I wouldnt trust Dominos for an exterior door. A big fat juicy mortise and tenon is simple and will provide heaps more strength.
 
Thanks for the replies guys. I was leaning towards using mortise and tenons for the rails and stiles but thought the dominos might be quicker. If I used the dominos, I was thinking I'd use 4 of the 10x50 per joint for strength.
 
Les, if you do go the way of Dominos, then why not use the 10mm cutter plunging in 28mm on the widest setting, and make some home made dominos to fit. That would be stronger.

When I make big domies, just before I insert and glue up, I put them in an engineers vice and give it a ¼ turn to compress them a little. After putting some glue in the mortise and on the home made Domi, it swells back and you get a brilliant fit that is not starved of glue.

PS, when you compress them they expand in width a little, so you need to take that into account when you rip the stock. Make them a mill or so less in width.
 
I understand the traditional thought processes that would seem to recommend bigger tenons, but several tests run by the mags indicate the joint is stronger than the wood they are in. If that is the case then the joints should be as strong as they need to be. If you do use more and/or follow Tezzer's suggestion to make you own wider ones then I'll bet you will covered very well.
 
Tezzer,

Like your suggestion for larger dominoes. I have a mortizer. Going to have to give it some more thought on which way to go. [blink]

Greg,

That's why I was considering the dominoes.
 
Brice Burrell said:
junk said:
This might be the link to doors made with domino that Tom and Brice are talking about.

http://festoolownersgroup.com/member-projects/entry-doors-with-side-lites/

John

That's it John, here's a direct link to the post in that thread that covers the loose tenon process. Entry Doors with side lites: loose tenons.  Les, I'd would use (and I have) the process Eiji used.

John and Brice,

Thanks for links. I'd forgotten about Eiji doors. I'm having a problem enlarging the thumb nail pic's. Is this a problem for others?
 
Tom Bellemare said:
I'm having a problem enlarging the thumb nail pic's. Is this a problem for others?

'Same here.

Tom

I believe (could be mistaken) Eiji removed his photo library (source) from the FOG...unfortunately all that's left now are the low rez thumbnails.
Tim
 
Back
Top