I need a good corded jig saw...

[elfick]

I'm leaning towards the Carvex. I'm aware of the tilt-base issue and I don't think it will affect me much (and I think either festool or someone else will offer a proper tilt base shortly). Is there another jig saw I should consider?

 

[Staniam]

I personally haven't found an issue with the angle base. I mean it'll take some practice like a lot of Festool stuff but I actually really enjoy the base. There are definitely members on here who hate it but I've also seen a good amount say they like it.

The Mafell is an option  [big grin]

Also the Bosch JS572EBL would be another good option.

Do you have a preference between barrel or D grip?

 

[elfick]

I'm definitely have a preference for the barrel grip. I was looking at the Bosch, though I'd probably go for the JS572EB and fit it into a systainer. The Carvex seems more advanced but I'd love to hear any personal comparisons.

 

[andy5405]

Have you considered the PS300, it's a cracking tool and a lot cheaper than the Carvex.

 

[Birdhunter]

I have both the Bosch and the Carvex. Dust collection pushes me toward the Festool jigsaw. Both are excellent products.

 

[Brent Taylor]

When I was looking to replace my 25 yr. old Makita, I looked at 4 saws: Makita's top of the line saws, Bosch's & the 4 corded Festool's. I ended up going with the top handled Carvex & if you check my other post on this saw you will see why I choose this saw. The only thing I could say is try all the ones you are looking at, hold them in you hands & cut some wood or metal if you can. Then make your choice. I know that the Maffel is the best on the market, but it's price point was beyond my limit for a tool that's used in the field.

 

[NHSP759]

I'm leaning towards the Carvex. I'm aware of the tilt-base issue and I don't think it will affect me much (and I think either festool or someone else will offer a proper tilt base shortly). Is there another jig saw I should consider?

I've got the Carvex and accessory kit. Love it. The Bosch is a really good saw too and CPO Bosch is having a Presidents' Day sale for the machine and l boxx at 15% off right now.

 

[Knight Woodworks]

I own a Trion. Demoed the Carvex and the Bosch barrel-grips. Bought a P1cc, if you can afford it, get the Mafell.

John

 

[waho6o9]

Hilti and a Carvex here, both great and use them often.

The Carvex has the edge with the light  [smile]

 

[elfick]

The Mafell definitely looks awesome but it isn't in the budget. The first job is going to be cutting foam board insulation so dust collection is a must and I'm not sure that the Bosch has that requirement covered (?). While the PS300 is a possibility, I think I'd rather get the 420 for $75 more. I dig the flexibility offered by the quick-change base and I prefer to get brush-less motors whenever possible.

 

[Brent Taylor]

The Mafell definitely looks awesome but it isn't in the budget. The first job is going to be cutting foam board insulation so dust collection is a must and I'm not sure that the Bosch has that requirement covered (?). While the PS300 is a possibility, I think I'd rather get the 420 for $75 more. I dig the flexibility offered by the quick-change base and I prefer to get brush-less motors whenever possible.

You will need to use the right blade & use a second vac. If it's 1 or 2# beadboard you will have a mess. I have built alot of homes & additions with SIP's (foam fill building panels) & it's messy.